Take our Family Estrangement Test for the Adult Child

Find a Family Therapy Therapist

South Asian families often balance tradition with adaptation.

The joint family system can offer support in the form of shared caregiving, financial pooling, and connection.

A joint family system can also foster blurred boundaries and hierarchy.

These dynamics raise a central question about the fine line between support and control.

“Before my parents moved to the U.S., my mom had lived with my dad’s parents for a few months while my dad found a job in the U.S.," explains Kalpana, 27. "When my mom joined the family, my dad’s older brother’s wife, who had been treated badly by the in-laws while living there, wanted the same treatment for my mom. So she plotted against her.”

Kalpana’s story is not an isolated one. What began as an intergenerational conflict in South Asia crossed oceans and resurfaced in New Jersey when her uncle’s family moved into their American home.

Kalpana recalls the emotional abuse her mother endured and how she and her brother absorbed the fallout. These early experiences shaped her sense of safety and belonging in ways that lingered in her adulthood.

The examples provided are taken from real-life scenarios, and all identifying information has been altered to ensure confidentiality.

Negotiating Family Traditions in the South Asian Diaspora

South Asian families often balance tradition with adaptation. These tensions show up in everyday decisions about family structure, marriage, and independence, and are shaped by background, education, acculturation, internalized belief systems, religion, and more.

In North America, these differences tend to become even more pronounced, given an individual’s desire to balance both cultural and mainstream societal values. In an interview with David Letterman, Bollywood star and former Miss World Aishwarya Rai Bachchan spoke proudly about the closeness she felt living with her parents as an adult—a sharp contrast with American expectations of early independence.

Yet while her experience resonates with many South Asians, others diverge. Some........

© Psychology Today