menu_open Columnists
Neil Mackay

Neil Mackay

Herald Scotland

We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Dry your eyes, Stephen Flynn. Why shouldn't the media scrutinise SNP spending?

Dry your eyes, Stephen Flynn. Why shouldn't the media scrutinise SNP spending?

It didn’t take me long as a young journalist to realise all was not well with my profession. I became a reporter long ago, in 1991. Margaret...

yesterday 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

SNP can either cosplay as social justice warriors or fight homelessness with Burnham

SNP can either cosplay as social justice warriors or fight homelessness with Burnham

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. I still recall the first time I saw someone sleeping rough. It was during a...

21.08.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Flogging this Scottish treasure to an overseas buyer is nothing but barbarism

Flogging this Scottish treasure to an overseas buyer is nothing but barbarism

THERE’S a distinct whiff of barbarism in the way Scotland’s elected officials in the Highlands are behaving today. The matter centres on the bust...

21.08.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Why everything feels broken: Three books that make sense of modern chaos

Why everything feels broken: Three books that make sense of modern chaos

The tragedy of my generation is that we were raised in a period when news and analysis moved slowly enough for even those who didn’t stay across...

20.08.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Jason Arday case shows the persecution of minorities has reached bloodthirsty levels

Jason Arday case shows the persecution of minorities has reached bloodthirsty levels

It should revolt the entire nation that a Scottish academic is scared to speak about her work because of the colour of her skin. I met with Melanie...

18.08.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Trapped between cowards and cranks, the SNP has left the indy movement to unravel

Trapped between cowards and cranks, the SNP has left the indy movement to unravel

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. All eyes are currently on the strange, whacky and cowardly behaviour of...

14.08.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Should I ride the fat-jag pony or embrace my fate as a middle-aged chubster?

I had a moment of intense middle-aged horror just before I went on my summer holiday. I was packing my suitcase and reached for my lovely...

13.08.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

This is great: I am so enjoying Nicola Sturgeon’s ‘couldn’t GAF’ attitude right now

Scotland seems divided into three distinct groups. There’s the 10% who obsessively hate Nicola Sturgeon. Hate is a strong word, but these folk...

10.08.2026 10

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

The Scottish legends at the heart of Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey

First, a brief review. Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey is magnificent. I’ve a few gripes, which drop it from an A to a mere A, but none are to do...

25.07.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Andy Burnham has just made a huge mistake over independence

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. We were so close, yet so far. So close you could almost taste it - like poor...

24.07.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Drill, baby, drill: We’re like Nero fiddling while Arthur’s Seat burns

I sometimes wonder whether much of the rage which swirls around these days is down to a collective sense of shame at our own suicidal stupidity as a...

23.07.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

If Burnham lives up to his promise, he kills the SNP and indy stone dead

I detest the type of person who is my age – mid-50s – and forever sneering at young folk. They forget we were once young – albeit in the last...

21.07.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Finally, there’s a way to put the Sturgeon-Salmond-Murrell scandals to bed

As matters stand today, Nicola Sturgeon will never get out from under the scandals that are plaguing her. Most political leaders leave office carrying...

17.07.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

How a £37 million T-Rex is the last gobble of the monster rich

It's impossible to be certain about how our ancestors lived in the ancient past. There’s no recorded history, after all. However, scholars are...

16.07.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Stop calling Farage ‘daddy’, you weirdos, you’re creeping everyone out

In Northern Ireland, where I’m from, there’s a weird, disturbing cultural quirk found in a minority of folk which, I’m afraid, gives me the...

14.07.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

New Lowe: Debasing Dunblane on Rogan show symbolises collapse of politics and media

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. Only the psychopathic or sadistic could remain untroubled by the depths to...

10.07.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Why some Scottish traditions need to die - get over it

I’ve a healthy distrust of tradition. Ironically, my suspicion was bred deep, from my formative years. It’s hard to respect tradition when...

09.07.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

From licence fee to subscriptions: what Sky’s £1.6bn ITV deal means for British TV

I imagine one day in the not-so-distant future sitting with my grandchildren on my knee and telling them wild fairy tales so unbelievable that the...

08.07.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

How money is killing democracy – now it’s time to take it back

Politics has always been about rich people and their money. Once it was courtiers fashioning themselves into camps to ensure they had the king’s...

06.07.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Welcome to Scotland in 2026 - where Blackshirts parade on our city streets

Thomas Weber, professor of history at Aberdeen University, is recognised as one of the world’s leading authorities on Adolf Hitler and the Nazis....

03.07.2026 60

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Andy Burnham? He’s just Labour’s version of Boris Johnson

If you’ve been wondering whether Andy Burnham is simply a Labour version of Boris Johnson, then you’re pretty much bang on the money. About to be...

02.07.2026 20

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Mamma mia: I've seen the future of entertainment and it scares the hell out of me

It wasn’t just the 35° heat melting my brain in London this weekend. My wife had sprung a surprise on me: front row tickets for the ABBA Voyage...

30.06.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Reform is stinking up Holyrood and the other parties are applying the air freshener

One of literature’s most famous opening lines comes in Leo Tolstoy’s Anna Karenina. “All happy families are alike; each unhappy family is...

26.06.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

From pies and stews to air-con and shorts: how warmer weather is changing Scots

Kurt Cobain once sang that ‘weather changes mood’. Always one for self-deprecating understatement, he pulled his punches in that line. Weather...

24.06.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

It’s the worst film ever made in Scotland so can we please cancel Highlander remake?

How could anyone have the arrogant audacity to remake Santa Claus Conquers the Martians?  Who would dare believe they had the power to improve...

23.06.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

We let politicians like Sturgeon play us for fools. Why do we tolerate it?

It astonishes me that anyone other than politicians would wish to associate with politicians. They’re an abysmal subsection of society. The...

23.06.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Why Andy Burnham creates a nightmare scenario for the SNP

Andy Burnham has certainly left plenty of folk shivering in their shoes. His win at Makerfield goes way beyond simply setting him on course to take...

19.06.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Want to clampdown on racist thugs rampaging in the streets? Then ban all face masks

Some years ago, I was developing a slightly high-falutin documentary about masks and the weird role they’ve played in human society. The mask is a...

18.06.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

The definition of this Age of Stupid: Musk as the world's first trillionaire

Even if Elon Musk wasn’t Elon Musk, even if Elon Musk was a good and noble man, even if Elon Musk was a planetary exemplar of decency and morality,...

16.06.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Claims that Israeli firm targeted Scottish elections require urgent investigation

The allegations only emerged on Thursday evening, so calm and logic are required. This isn’t an issue which should be subject to the distortions of...

12.06.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Britain on the brink as Belfast and Glasgow erupt - so what happens next?

We're descending into ever tightening, ever more rapid, cycles of savagery. In Belfast, unspeakable violence is met with pogroms. We see this...

10.06.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Why Alan Cumming's Tip Toe is the TV show we need right now

In the most troubling way, the timing of Tip Toe couldn’t have been more horribly perfect.  On the day the final gruelling episode aired on Channel...

10.06.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

How dare the middle classes sneer at families who are going hungry?

I spent a chunk of last week talking to the folk behind the UK Right to Food Commission. There are 14 million people going hungry in Britain today,...

09.06.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

If Westminster can investigate Holyrood, then Holyrood should investigate Westminster

Most people, even many SNP stalwarts, agree that there should be an inquiry into the Peter Murrell embezzlement case. I accord with Noel Dolan, once...

05.06.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Farage whistles and the dogs run to riot … and desecrate the memory of Henry Nowak

Desecration piles upon desecration. The reputation of Henry Nowak: desecrated with lies that he was racist. His life: desecrated by the bestial...

04.06.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Let's talk: here’s one sure way to fix Scotland’s broken schools, kids and society

One of my most important formative experiences happened in April 1982 during the Falklands War. I was 12 and in first year at my Northern Ireland...

02.06.2026 30

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Sturgeon has questions to answer - but only as a politician, not as a wife

Like many, I initially responded to news that Nicola Sturgeon’s former husband was guilty of embezzling £400,000 from the SNP with the thought:...

29.05.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Blair isn’t the saviour of Labour, but he will be its undertaker

I hope my grandad forgives me, but he was the first person who came to mind when I saw Tony Blair had crept out of his crypt to pontificate about the...

28.05.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Unionism is done in Scotland. It no longer has a story to tell the people

It's quite a mouthful for a book’s title, but I recommend A Psychiatric Study of Myths and Fairytales: Their Origin, Meaning and Usefulness by...

26.05.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

The widespread failure to tell the truth about immigration is profoundly dangerous

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. You may have missed it, as the news has been very poorly reported in the...

22.05.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Why must stable Scotland put up with all this English chaos and nonsense?

If we don our surgical gloves, reach for the handsaw, and pop the Scottish and UK governments onto the anatomy table for a spot of dissection, it...

21.05.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Mindless hooligans won't change their ways so the football clubs need to suffer

A Scottish referee is given police protection because of a penalty. A trans MSP is escorted through Holyrood by security guards due to fears for their...

18.05.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Memo to Labour: Andy Burnham is not the Messiah, he’s just a very average boy

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. If you’ve been watching a lot of TV news these last few days, you may have...

15.05.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Why the next wave of tech will turn ordinary people into voyeurs and spies

I confess my bias from the get-go: I hate technology. Not all technology, I hasten to add. I don’t hate heart machines and radios, or satnavs and...

14.05.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

The end for the UK is nigh: Celtic nationalists will ally to kill off the Union

The Labour/Tory duopoly is collapsing and with it the political system. The future is a battle of nationalisms between Reform, SNP, Sinn Fein and...

12.05.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

The people have spoken – there will be a pro-indy majority but it will be ignored

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. There’s something deeply absurd and offensive about the way democracy in...

08.05.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

So, how the hell did I end up with a 30-year old-daughter?

I almost burned down my mother-in-law’s house when I learned I was about to become a dad for the first time. And she was a brand new mother-in-law,...

07.05.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Bookmark this: what the adverts we see today say about the state of Scotland

Where once there were adverts for real physical books, today there’s only adverts for celebrity audiobooks. This reveals something very troubling,...

05.05.2026 40

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Why Scotland's top policy expert says no party offers Scotland what it needs

Stephen Boyd heads the influential think tank the Institute for Public Policy Research Scotland. As the election looms, writer-at-large Neil Mackay...

03.05.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay

Is the SNP prepared for what happens if it wins next week? Short answer: No

This article appears as part of the Unspun: Scottish Politics newsletter. You'd be hard pushed to claim this Scottish election has been anything...

01.05.2026 50

Herald Scotland

Neil Mackay