menu_open Columnists
Isabel Hardman

Isabel Hardman

Independent

We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Burnham can’t keep being a people pleaser

Andy Burnham had a reasonable first outing at Prime Minister’s Questions today. He didn’t flounder, but he didn’t make it look easy, either. He...

latest 6

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

How is Burnham different to Starmer?

What is Andy Burnham really going to do that’s different from his predecessor? When he made his first address to MPs as prime minister yesterday,...

latest 8

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Has Andy Burnham considered the consequences of early releases?

Victims will start receiving letters from today informing them that they will be affected by the early release of prisoners, after Andy Burnham...

yesterday 8

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

How radical does Andy Burnham want to be?

Is Andy Burnham running a ‘circuit breaker’ government from the one led by Keir Starmer, or is it a ‘continuity’ administration? Chancellor...

28.08.2026 20

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Burnham’s council housing pledge falls short

We are starting to see a pattern in the announcements that Andy Burnham has made over his first few weeks as Prime Minister. He makes a promise...

26.08.2026 20

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Britain is in for a difficult autumn

How hard is this autumn going to be? This week’s economic figures suggest pretty hard: job losses, higher-than-expected borrowing, and higher...

22.08.2026 20

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Why Burnham might regret his No.10 North plan

How realistic is Andy Burnham’s plan to make No. 10 North responsible for the government’s ‘growth mission’? The Prime Minister’s argument...

19.08.2026 20

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Should Prevent be scrapped?

The warning from the Children’s Commissioner that the Prevent programme can’t help ‘a cohort of children intoxicated by extremism’ might...

19.08.2026 10

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Will Yvette Cooper’s new mental health centres offer anything new?

Are mental health centres in libraries, banks and high street locations really going to make much of a difference? Health Secretary Yvette Cooper has...

06.08.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Andy Burnham must get used to being unpopular

Andy Burnham is apparently enjoying his first taste of unpopularity as prime minister, in the form of the furore over the early release of domestic...

05.08.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Even I am considered disabled - what qualifies for PIP has to change

Given she has been the most consistent figure in British politics in the past 20 years, Louise Casey is worth listening to far more than any of the...

31.07.2026 30

iNews

Isabel Hardman

Burnham won’t reform social care with ‘cross-party consensus’

Does Andy Burnham really believe that cross-party consensus is going to resolve the decades-long stalemate on the funding of adult social care? Of...

29.07.2026 10

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Burnham must also tackle the quality of Britain’s social care

Andy Burnham knows that ‘fixing’ social care will drain political capital away from him faster than a teenager emptying their parents’ bank...

27.07.2026 20

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Burnham won't upset pensioners. He may end up upsetting everyone else

Does Andy Burnham’s claim this week that his government is a “second chance at a first impression” make any sense? What the new Prime Minister...

23.07.2026 20

iNews

Isabel Hardman

Anas Sarwar’s peerage is hardly a surprise

To the surprise of very few in Scottish politics, bar apparently himself, Anas Sarwar is stepping down as leader of the Scottish Labour party to take...

22.07.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Does Burnham really know how to change Britain?

Andy Burnham told his Cabinet this morning that they need to give people a ‘sense that help is coming’. He was largely focused on the cost of...

21.07.2026 20

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Yvette Cooper is a left-field choice for Health Secretary

What does Yvette Cooper as Health Secretary mean for the NHS? It’s a question no one thought to ask before today, which underlines why her...

21.07.2026 20

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

No, we don’t need a better tone at PMQs

Keir Starmer has been quite an irritable – and irritating at times – performer in the Commons as prime minister. His sessions with Kemi Badenoch...

17.07.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

It wasn’t all cosy at Starmer’s final PMQs

It’s difficult for an outgoing Prime Minister to mess up their valedictory PMQs: there is always more goodwill in the Chamber on those occasions...

15.07.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Burnham’s HR whips department won’t work

Now that he’s officially the Prime Minister in waiting, Andy Burnham is trying to work out how to stop Labour MPs from turning against him in the...

10.07.2026 20

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

The most appalling thing about the NHS maternity scandal

By the end of this year, Britain will have had (at least) seven prime ministers in the past decade – and more than 700 recommendations on how to...

25.06.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Did Kemi Badenoch take the personal jibes too far at PMQs?

Keir Starmer came to PMQs wearing that look of post-resignation relief that we’ve grown all too used to seeing on a prime minister’s face over the...

24.06.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Burnham says he’ll cut benefits. It might just break him

Now that Labour MPs seem confident that Andy Burnham is the only possible answer to whatever question their party has been asking over the past few...

22.06.2026 30

iNews

Isabel Hardman

Starmer’s tears show why he failed as PM

Keir Starmer looked visibly emotional as he walked up to the lectern in Downing Street this morning. The Prime Minister then held it together for the...

22.06.2026 20

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

The most reluctant inhabitant of Burnham's No 10 will be his most important

There was a telling moment in Andy Burnham’s second bid to be Labour leader where he was put firmly in place by his own wife. The pair had sat down...

19.06.2026 40

iNews

Isabel Hardman

David Lammy’s heart wasn’t in DPMQs

Claire Coutinho emerged as the Tory frontbencher taking deputy prime minister’s questions today, with the shadow energy secretary focusing on oil...

17.06.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Will Burnham avoid the Starmer trap?

Voters in Makerfield haven’t even gone to the polling stations, but already the Labour leadership contest is well into a detailed exposition of what...

16.06.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

A&E is broken. Can anyone fix it?

‘Corridor care’ should be an oxymoron, but is instead such a feature of the NHS now that nearly 3,000 people a day found themselves being treated...

13.06.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Keir Starmer’s weakness was on display at PMQs

Prime Minister’s Questions today was ostensibly about the Defence Investment Plan – or its absence. But Kemi Badenoch was really using the DIP in...

10.06.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Starmer is in survival mode – but for what purpose?

Keir Starmer is using this morning’s cabinet meeting to underline the message he has been sending to more junior ministers over the past few days:...

09.06.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

The irony of Keir Starmer’s plan to fund defence

Where could the government possibly find the money to fund its defence investment plan (DIP)? That question has been the major factor behind the...

08.06.2026 40

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

The strange state of Labour’s leadership contest

Andy Burnham finally confirmed last night that he is indeed standing for the Labour leadership – just in case anyone was confused about what the...

05.06.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Emotional politicians create bad policies

We have now reached the stage of political debate around Henry Nowak’s murder where politicians are talking more about tone policing than they are...

04.06.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Starmer and Badenoch can’t avoid the politics of Henry Nowak’s death

Kemi Badenoch clearly decided that it would be difficult to call for calm around the Henry Nowak case, and then to spend Prime Minister’s Questions...

03.06.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Labour’s humiliation is brutal – but everyone is missing the real story

The latest tranche of files about Lord Peter Mandelson’s appointment as ambassador to Washington contains some big surprises. Who would have...

01.06.2026 40

iNews

Isabel Hardman

Don’t bet on the next Labour leader solving the social care crisis

It’s refreshing that social care has become a topic over which the putative Labour leadership contenders are prepared to scrap, given how neglected...

29.05.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Streeting has abandoned the NHS like everyone else

As well as making noises about wealth taxes that sound suspiciously similar to the kind of thing Andy Burnham would normally say, Wes Streeting has...

21.05.2026 20

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

The real reason Wes Streeting is backing a wealth tax

What is Wes Streeting up to? For years – decades, in fact – the answer to that question was always, “He wants to be prime minister”. The...

21.05.2026 40

iNews

Isabel Hardman

It’s no surprise that Starmer’s ‘pompous’ tone annoys voters

Keir Starmer probably found it vaguely comforting that today’s Prime Minister’s Questions at least gave the impression that he is still making...

20.05.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Starmer’s King’s Speech response bore little resemblance to reality

Like the rest of the King’s Speech, Keir Starmer’s address on the government’s legislative agenda had been prepared long before the turmoil in...

13.05.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Jess Phillips’s resignation will be particularly painful for Keir Starmer

All three of the resignation letters from ministers who have quit government in the past couple of hours will be painful for Keir Starmer, but Jess...

12.05.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

It’s all too late for Keir Starmer

Keir Starmer’s big survival speech could nevler be big enough to save him as Prime Minister. Whether he ends up getting the push now or later in the...

11.05.2026 20

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Keir Starmer hasn’t done enough to save himself

The final Prime Minister’s Questions of a parliamentary session is often quite a demob-happy affair with a pantomime atmosphere. Today’s, though,...

29.04.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

What is the argument for keeping Keir Starmer?

For something that’s apparently only a ‘desperate political stunt’, Keir Starmer is taking the looming vote on whether to refer him to the...

27.04.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Did Keir Starmer watch the same Olly Robbins as me?

It will come as no surprise that Keir Starmer appears to have heard a very different evidence session from Sir Olly Robbins to the one everyone else...

22.04.2026 50

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Olly Robbins hits back over Mandelson’s vetting

Sir Olly Robbins has only been giving evidence to the foreign affairs committee for 20 minutes, and already he has made clear that he is not going to...

21.04.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Lee Anderson and Zarah Sultana are two sides of the same coin

What a funny pair Lee Anderson and Zarah Sultana are: so vehemently opposed to one another’s politics and yet so similar in the way they operate,...

20.04.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Starmer wants to ask, not answer, the questions at PMQs

Keir Starmer gave six responses to questions about Lord Robertson’s defence spending comments today, none of which addressed the criticism properly....

15.04.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Why I still watch PMQs

Is Prime Minister’s Questions past it? We frequently ask this question in Westminster when the Wednesday lunchtime ding-dong between the two party...

15.04.2026 30

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman

Will Starmer fix any of Britain’s big problems?

George Robertson’s critique of the government’s reluctance to commit to proper defence spending is deeply politically inconvenient for Keir...

14.04.2026 40

The Spectator

Isabel Hardman