menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

On the Ballot: Do debates really matter?

39 0
15.10.2026

On the Ballot: Do debates really matter?

Midterm debate season is in full swing, giving candidates a chance to square off with their rivals and make their pitch to voters as Election Day nears. But can debates really move the needle in this cycle’s competitive races?  

Senate candidates debated this week in battleground states Maine, Iowa and Georgia, trading barbs and snagging viral clips. At the same time, viewers have yet to see side-by-side debates for the Senate races in Texas and Ohio, two of the cycle’s most competitive upper chamber fights, or for the toss-up gubernatorial races in Nevada and Ohio.   

Despite concerns about low viewership for TV showdowns and the risks of an onstage stumble, experts say debates still make a difference: A standout performance or major gaffe could be a make-or-break moment for a political hopeful.  

“The debates matter question — I mean, why don’t you ask [former President] Joe Biden?” Philippe Reines, a veteran strategist who worked with former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton and former Vice President Kamala Harris on debate preparation. “That’s an extreme, but people have lost debates or they’ve sealed their fate or there’s been an opportunity cost. It’s really hard.”

A feeble debate performance against now-President Trump changed the trajectory ofBiden’s 2024 reelection bid, eventually leading to his historic exit from the race. It’s just one example of debate performances that have effectively doomed campaigns, from John F. Kennedy’s first-ever televised debate against Richard Nixon in 1960, to now-Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s showdown with then-New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie in the 2016 presidential race.  

But it’s hard to map how debate reactions translate to votes, and the age-old question of whether debates matter is surfacing again this cycle, as several candidates on both sides of the aisle are scaling back or opting out.  

Former Atlanta Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms, the Democrat nominee for governor in Georgia, faced off last week in a debate with Republican Rick Jackson. On Tuesday, however, she answered questions solo in a debate that Jackson formally declined to take part in.   

In Nevada, the Democratic gubernatorial nominee, state Attorney General Aaron Ford, answered questions last week beside an empty podium after incumbent Nevada Gov. Joe Lombardo (R) declined to participate.   

In Texas, state Rep. James Talarico (D) has continued to call for a debate with Republican Ken Paxton in their closely watched Senate race. Trump notably encouraged the Texas attorney general to do so, but Talarico appeared alone Wednesday night in a town hall hosted by CNN and Jubilee.  

The candidates appearing solo are “trying to make hay out of their opponent refusing to debate,” said Craig Hennigan, a lecturer and director of the University of Nevada, Las Vegas, debate program.   

“It doesn’t matter as much what they’re saying in those spaces. What matters is the fact that there is an empty podium next to them … trying to access those voters who think that presenting yourself publicly in a debate is a necessary part of the democratic process.”

Whether they’re debating their rival or alone on stage, candidates are trying to lasso the attention not just of the live audience, but the far reaches of the digital campaign trail.  

“Every debater, strategist, coach’s dream is for something in debate to really resonate and go viral on Instagram or TikTok or, you know, any kind of social media forums,” said Aaron Kall, the director of........

© The Hill