menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Endorsement: Prop I is a cocktail of poison pills masquerading as a housing fix

101 0
05.10.2026

It’s a rare day when San Francisco’s building trade unions lock arms with the Chamber of Commerce to march in solidarity against a tax measure.

Yet that’s exactly what’s happening with Proposition I on the November ballot.

Prop I purports to be the “only measure on the ballot that guarantees both innovative social housing and ongoing rental assistance.” Advanced by the Democratic Socialists of America, it would cement into law a real estate transfer tax that voters ratified in 2020, but this time place the revenue collected in a new restricted fund. At least 60% of that money would fund subsidized housing production, 25% to preservation and acquisition, and 10% to tenant stabilization and homelessness prevention. Properties valued from $10 million to $25 million would be taxed at 5.5%, while properties valued at $25 million or more would face a 6% levy.

Article continues below this ad

Sounds reasonable, perhaps. But scratch the surface, and it is anything but.

The measure’s text dedicates no less than half its housing production money toward “social housing.” That term means a lot of different things to a lot of different people. San Francisco has an existing definition of social housing in its code. But Leigh Lutenski, director of development at San Francisco’s Office of Workforce and Economic Development, told the editorial board that Prop I amends that definition. “It refers to the existing code but then adds required elements that don’t exist within........

© San Francisco Chronicle