menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Not ‘Manifest’ but an ‘Inclusive’ Destiny: A Case for Decolonizing Space Exploration

121 0
26.10.2026

Scientists, scholars, and space enthusiasts have long envisioned humans traveling to distant galaxies and settling on different planets, making space exploration a subject of much interest to scientists and social scientists. The technological feasibility of space travel, alongside the fears of imminent global destruction, has prompted thinkers such as Arthur C. Clarke (1959) and Buckminster Fuller (1969) to write about the inevitability of humans colonizing other planets (Spencer, 2017). However, in the last century, scientists have also been trying to pursue such ambitions seriously.  It was indeed around World War I, the Russian Revolution, and economic depression in the USSR that the Soviet Engineer Konstantin Tsiolkovsky had begun to conceptualize early ideas of space travel and rocketry. He believed that the “cosmos could offer an alternative space for human settlement” (Cornish, 2019, para. 4). Space was consequently described as a ‘new frontier’ that “represented the zenith of human accomplishment” (Cornish, 2019).

*Originally published in 2025 and preserved as part of our archive project.Get E-International Relations delivered to your inbox, free of charge. As you sign up, consider becoming a paid subscriber to support our work.

The First Space Age began with the launch of the Soviet Union’s ‘Sputnik 1’ in 1957. This was followed by the US’s Apollo missions in the 1960s, officially heralding an era when the two superpowers competed feverishly amidst the Cold War ideological rivalry to secure technological and military supremacy in space. This era also gave traction to concerns related to the “modes and kinds” of space projects that would be undertaken. These concerns were ratcheted up primarily because the foray into the space age was being driven by the Cold War arms race (Bormann and Sheehan, 2009:1). Until the end of the Cold War, the activities associated with space were driven by the “bipolar nuclear confrontation”. These early years were overshadowed by the US underlining the need to militarize and securitize outer space against the threat of a ‘communist cosmos’. This totalizing vision of space for half a century raised pertinent questions related to humanity’s relations to outer space that encompassed the realms of “the global, the international, the political, the ethical, the scientific,” and so on (Bormann and Sheehan, 2009:1).

While this totalizing view of seeking supremacy in space persisted even after the end of the Cold War, which marked the beginning of the second space age, it was conjoined by the ‘urgency’ to redefine the modes of space activities. The last three decades have witnessed a sharp increase in the privatization of space projects. The most glaring example of this endeavor is evident from the attempts made by states to ‘revitalize’ their space policies. For instance, in 2004, US President George Bush proclaimed the importance of a “new vision for America’s civilian and scientific space programme” (Bormann and Sheehan, 2009:2). This eventually led to the Report of the President’s Commission on Implementation of the United States Space Exploration Policy, A Journey to Inspire, Innovate, and Discover (2004).

The commission generated debate over its implicit call for colonization of space and the explicit recommendation for privatization and commercialization of space exploration. It also endorsed the presence of private actors in outer space (Bormann and Sheehan, 2009:2). Consequently, a decade later, contemporary technocrats such as Elon Musk and Jeff Bezos are spending billions of dollars on space exploration projects that may eventually lead to colonizing other planets such as Mars (Holland and Burns, 2018). However, recent discussions among scholars and scientists have pointed towards taking another look at how we approach the idea of space exploration. The questions such as “who gets to go, who will be in control, how new resources will be obtained and distributed, and the very language we use when talking about ‘exploration’, ‘discovery’ and colonization’” are being debated (Mandelbaum, 2018).

Coloniality in Space Exploration

While interplanetary travel is presented as a valuable endeavor, in which space explorers will visit other planets and colonize them, it has also been termed by some scholars as a ‘renewed form of settler colonialism’—the legacy of colonization on Earth that had led to disastrous consequences such as genocide, displacement of Indigenous communities and cultures, economic inequalities and the degradation of the environment (Dunbar-Ortiz, 2014; Saini, 2019; Painter, 2010; Bhandar, 2018). It is, therefore, imperative for space explorers to understand the history and legacy of colonialism on Earth to help discern how seemingly innocent curiosity to explore space is entrenched in colonial behaviors (Mandelbaum, 2018).

In The Half Life of Empire in Outer Space, Peter Redfield underscores the colonial impulse in space exploration “through and beyond the age of empire” (Redfield, 2002:791). Along the lines of Dipesh Chakrabarty’s Provincializing Europe, he provincializes outer space, which provided a prospect for a new form of settler colonialism, as an arena supposedly free from the history of imperialism on earth. The French colony Kourou, French Guiana, with its legacy of centuries of colonialism, has long served as a launching pad for the French space programmes, and is a case in point. It was a former penal colony of France, called ‘Devil’s Island’, that later became a ‘department’ of France. It is currently one of the few territories under European control in the Americas that continues to be used for space launches. This colony represents an uneasy bridge between modernity, represented by the space projects and the space centre, and perennial issues of inequalities and poverty (Redfield, 2002). In 2017, the people of French Guiana protested at the site of the Guiana Space Centre, chanting “we’ve had enough” in response to the inflation and poor living conditions (D’Auria and Fernholz, 2017, para. 2). In other words, French Guiana may well be considered as a space colony on earth, which evinces the consequences of coloniality in space exploration.

After the end of the Cold War, the domination of space based solely on ideology—the fear of a communist cosmos—was no longer viable. In the 1990s, the argument for American technological supremacy in space was justified on the grounds of imminent competition from European and East Asia countries. This new era saw the invocation of the imperial era’s concept of ‘frontierism’—proposed initially by Frederick Jackson Turner in 1893 in his essay The Significance of the Frontier in American History—supposedly an inherent part of the individualism in the US’s political and economic thought.

Alan Marshall describes frontierism as:

A........

© E-International