Fact-based journalism that sparks the Canadian conversation

Articles Business Environment Health Politics Arts & Culture Society

Special Series Hope You’re Well For the Love of the Game Living Rooms In Other Worlds: A Space Exploration Terra Cognita More special series >

For the Love of the Game

In Other Worlds: A Space Exploration

More special series >

Events The Walrus Talks The Walrus Video Room The Walrus Leadership Roundtables The Walrus Leadership Forums Article Club

The Walrus Video Room

The Walrus Leadership Roundtables

The Walrus Leadership Forums

Subscribe Renew your subscription Change your address Magazine Issues Newsletters Podcasts

Renew your subscription

The Walrus Lab Hire The Walrus Lab Amazon First Novel Award

Amazon First Novel Award

Who Really Runs Canada? Inside Mark Carney’s Influence Network

Government priorities increasingly reflect the interests of a small, well-connected elite

Rockcliffe Park is as lovely a neighbourhood as you can find in this country. It has large, secluded yards and calm, shady streets. Its residents’ stately manors and homes are nestled between the river, forests, and a semi-private lake, which the plebes are only welcome to swim in upon invitation from owners of private docks along its shore. Some of Ottawa’s best private schools claim the neighbourhood as their home, and the residents’ association is certainly one of the city’s best resourced.

Rockcliffe Park also houses a significant portion of the capital’s decision makers and gross domestic product.

The prime minister and governor general live there. The leader of the opposition shares a backyard fence with the high commissioner of India. There are so many diplomats hanging around, their neighbourhood block parties may now have to register on the foreign interference registry. Venerable public servants, a handful of journalists, business leaders, and, of course, lobbyists rub shoulders on the hiking trails or at the sailing club.

In 2024, Mark Carney—then just one of the illustrious members of the Rockcliffe community—was the headliner for the association’s speaker series. He was described by the association president as “our Mark,” before he spoke to a packed fieldhouse crowd, which included Joe Clark as well as probably more members of the Order of Canada than any other room in the nation.

Rockcliffe isn’t the star of this story. I don’t mean to bother the good people who live there. But I happen to be fascinated with the connections between this country’s handful of policy influencers, business people, politicians, media pundits, and moguls who run much of Canada. There are neighbourhoods quite similar to Rockcliffe across the country. Not all of them hold the same level of power, but all share common characteristics: safe and quiet streets, good or excellent infrastructure, access to nature or, at a minimum, ample green space, and a great chance of residents being put in touch with the right people.

I don’t believe any of this is a conspiracy. Rich and influential people have wanted to live among one another since tribes started to settle down in the earliest days of Mesopotamia. But as we experience a widening chasm between what Canadians want and the policies they are being given, I believe there is value in examining where the government is getting their ideas from. And part of the answer, I believe, resides in the circles in which our decision makers exist.

There has been a disconnect for some time between this government’s priorities and those of the average Canadian. The easiest example of this mismatch is on the issue of AI. This government has gone full speed ahead on artificial intelligence, despite Canadians’ apprehensions. Smarter people than I have dug into this better than I ever could, so I won’t say more. But you get it: Carney wants to go in one direction, Canadians disagree, he does it anyway.

In a report on extreme wealth released by the nonprofit Canadians for Tax Fairness, the authors found that “extreme wealth concentration is a problem not because it allows a few people to live lives of luxury, but because of the extreme concentration of power and the corrosion of democracy that can accompany it.” This is true for Rockcliffe but probably even more true in well-to-do Toronto, Calgary, and Vancouver neighbourhoods.

Much as small-c conservatives and their cousins even further to the populist right like to think of themselves as exempt from the Birkenstock-wearing, murse-toting, bicycle-riding, matcha-drinking urbanite intelligentsia, the business leaders they so idolize and seek to please are oftentimes engaged in the neighbourhood associations and business improvement areas which make those well-heeled places so pleasant. My favourite example of this is Jordan Peterson spouting nonsense about the fifteen-minute-cities hysteria when he, in fact, lived and worked in one of the country’s most walkable—and unaffordable—neighbourhoods in Toronto.

The majority of Canadians don’t live in such pleasant environments. Contrary to what European tourists might........

© The Walrus