I keep seeing comments online blaming Benjamin Netanyahu for a wide range of problems, including the rise in antisemitism. The argument often goes something like this: if Israel had a different leader, global hostility toward the country would decline.

Whether Netanyahu has made policy mistakes or served in office for too long is a separate and valid discussion, but it is not the same as linking him directly to the rise of antisemitism.

Public debate about Israel often revolves around personalities. Much of the criticism directed at Israel internationally in recent years has been tied to Netanyahu’s leadership. Supporters of this view argue that his policies, rhetoric, and political alliances have fueled international anger and contributed to a rise in anti-Israel sentiment.

The implication is clear. If Israel were led by someone else, perhaps a more centrist or conciliatory figure, the hostility toward Israel might diminish significantly.

But history suggests a different conclusion. While Israeli leaders certainly shape policy and tone, the global backlash against Israel has persisted across governments of different political stripes. Looking at previous Israeli prime ministers and major events in the conflict reveals that criticism, protests, and sometimes outright antisemitism have emerged regardless of who occupies the prime minister’s office.

One example is the premiership of Naftali Bennett, who led Israel from 2021 to 2022. Bennett was not Netanyahu. He led a diverse coalition government that included parties from across the Israeli political spectrum,........

© The Times of Israel (Blogs)