Years ago, in the midst of a dating spree that involved numerous encounters with erratic and callous young men, I often consulted my cousin. She’s a cool, emotionally controlled New Yorker who seemed to have an innate knowledge of how to seize and maintain power in sexual or would-be sexual entanglements. She often advised me to nix the wordy message I had planned, especially in response to an outrageous slight, like a last-minute cancellation with a crap excuse and an insincere apology, and send a single yellow thumbs up instead. This was the craftier, nastier update on the cumbrous and obscene big blue thumb from Facebook messenger.

For those of us who panic at blankness, the thumb is psychological botulism

Her advice was clever. The thumbs up was clearly cold, oozing with disdain and passive aggression, but was unassailable – you can’t tell someone to calm down, or accuse them of being over the top, or emotionally incontinent if they send a thumbs up. It says: ‘I don’t care because you’re beneath caring’. It says: ‘OK dude, whatever, your actions don’t really matter apart from being mildly annoying’. It is, in short, in human psychological terms, a massive thumbs down: an obliteration, death by apathy and insouciant, carefree dismissal. You don’t matter one bit, it says.

And I felt great after sending it. I felt powerful, like I’d delivered a blow no wordy message could. And it usually worked – either the men were too tone-deaf to suspect I was not literally approving of their message, or they were piqued by its remoteness. Since then, WhatsApp has upped the reactions ante, so that instead of having to occupy a whole message window with a chosen emoji you can now react to a given message. July 2022 saw the first core menu for these ‘quick reactions’, before they were widened out to include all of them – but it’s the thumbs up that seems to be used most.

QOSHE - The unbearable rudeness of the thumbs up emoji - Zoe Strimpel
menu_open
Columnists Actual . Favourites . Archive
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close
Aa Aa Aa
- A +

The unbearable rudeness of the thumbs up emoji

8 1
19.02.2024

Years ago, in the midst of a dating spree that involved numerous encounters with erratic and callous young men, I often consulted my cousin. She’s a cool, emotionally controlled New Yorker who seemed to have an innate knowledge of how to seize and maintain power in sexual or would-be sexual entanglements. She often advised me to nix the wordy message I had planned, especially in response to an outrageous slight, like a last-minute cancellation with a crap excuse and an........

© The Spectator


Get it on Google Play