Grok can launch a thousand ships – but this AI remake of the Odyssey can’t make us feel
Imagine a father pretending to be mad because he wants to stay with his son and his family and not go to war. When his son’s life is in danger, he is forced to disclose the truth and is obliged to leave his son to go to war.
This is a heart-breaking story, but when artificial intelligence created it, critics found it unmoving, motiveless and meaningless.
The seven-minute film introducing the story of the Odyssey was made by Elon Musk’s Grok Imagine system, and is the first episode in what is planned to be a full-length feature.
Guardian film critic Peter Bradshaw said it had an “uncanny-valley stock-footage quality”. The Telegraph called it “sloppy gruesomeness”, while Rolling Stone noted viewers found the acting “soulless” and “wooden”.
The occasional reviewer has been slightly more muted in their criticism, finding brief visual moments that worked. Tech Crunch said “a few individual shots might provide a reasonable simulacrum of reality”, and in Digital Trends, Paulo Vargas wrote:
Some of the best shots […] don’t contain actors. Ancient landscapes stretch into the distance. Close-ups of grimy hands suggest people who have touched something rougher than a keyboard. For a few seconds, the illusion holds.
Some of the best shots […] don’t contain actors. Ancient landscapes stretch into the........
