BACK in the deep past, it’s thought our ancient ancestors consumed kings and queens, literally ate them, probably after death. At the root of this ‘regiphagy’ there likely lay some strange belief that royal power could be transferred through an act of cannibalism.

We clearly haven’t changed very much, given the disturbing way British society is wolfing down the story of Catherine, Princess of Wales and her photoshopped pictures.

Once again, as a republican, I find myself feeling sympathy for a royal. I don’t hate the individuals in the royal family, I hate the institution. The royals themselves are human beings like you and I; they feel the same pain and shame we do. So, it’s hard not to empathise with Kate, pilloried and mocked as she is now, a million times a minute on social media across the world.

In a way, this is a nothing-story. A celebrity - for what’s royalty but the final rung on the showbiz ladder - photoshopped a picture. Big deal. Who cares?

Let’s try to exercise some empathy and consider why Kate might have edited the image. She’s a woman whose every move is studied like a specimen under a microscope. She was ill and underwent an operation. She then came under intense scrutiny for not being in the public eye. Soon, most of Britain was making jokes about her ‘disappearance’.

Catherine, Princess of Wales lives her life in the public eye (Image: free)

I’m trying hard not to be too po-faced here. The jokes were funny. I made some too. But unlike Kate, I wasn’t sitting at home - albeit that home is a palace - and reading this stuff.

Nor was all of it funny, or intended to be funny. Some revelled in cruelty, others genuinely believe something terrible has happened to Kate - that’s she’s been murdered - or she’s done something terrible.

In her situation, might you not stick out a picture to shut the mob up? Yes, it was thoroughly stupid to edit the image, but she’s a celebrity, and for celebrities image is everything. And if she’s sick and exhausted, is it such a crime to tweak a picture to make herself or her family look a little more attractive? It might sound silly and mundane, but people are often silly and mundane.

However, I’m split about this story. Part of me sees it as the nothing-story I just outlined - ‘Celebrity recovering from surgery puts out photoshopped image to quell intrusion from the press and public’. Yet, another part of me sees some rather important truths emerging.

There’s clearly an issue about royal accountability. The royals are part of British democracy, therefore they must be trustworthy. And yes, I know, it’s a fair question to ask ‘when have they ever been trustworthy?’. But I’m talking here about the theory not the practice of British democracy.

Royals shouldn’t lie to us, even over some minor issue like tweaked pictures. Kate lied. She’s damaged the concept of trust.

However, that point feels rather draconian in its utopianism, like trying to demand no MP lies, or every voter reads Hansard and studies economics.

What’s more troubling about this story isn’t the behaviour of the royals, but us, the people. Many of us are grossly hypocritical: pretending the royals don’t interest us, while gobbling them down like our Stone Age ancestors.

READ MORE:

Neil Mackay: Britain’s ‘love affair’ with the royals is actually a sick S&M relationship

Neil Mackay: Tidal wave of hate towards the Queen made me ashamed to be republican

Neil Mackay: We need to be able to discuss abolishing the monarch without fear of arrest

Hypocrisy aside, though, this story reveals another hunger in humanity: our insatiable need for conspiracy theories. Millions suddenly became experts in photoshop. I’ve worked in the media for more than 30 years, and I couldn’t see the edits in that Kate picture.

Maybe I’m stupid. Maybe I should’ve gone to Specsavers. But I saw nothing. Who has time to subject pictures to microscopic investigation? And more importantly why?

Again, while most social media posts were just silly jokes about Kate ‘disappearing’, others brutally ridiculed her - a sick woman - and many genuinely believe she’s been hurt. Some think she’s been body-swapped.

In America, speculation about the state of her marriage has reached grotesque levels. Have people really forgotten what such intrusion did to the woman who would have been Kate’s mother-in-law, Princess Diana?

People turn to conspiracy theories when all trust is gone - not just trust in the royals, but trust in everything. That really matters. The frenzy over these pictures says something very significant about how so few of us have any faith left in the pillars of society, from the press to the government.

We also seem to have embraced this story as a distraction from the horrors occurring around the world. That’s understandable, but isn’t it sad? Doesn’t it make you feel pity for the human race? We’re inflicting such terrible, relentless cruelties on ourselves that we must seek sanctuary in a story as discomfiting as this - a story about a sick woman doctoring pictures to keep the public off her back?

Princess Diana (Image: free)

The greatest lesson, though, from this strange and sorry saga is that in the 21st century reality has become very slippery indeed. This year, there will be history-making elections all around the planet. Digital manipulation - from deep fakes of audio and video, to state-sponsored online disinformation - will be the backdrop.

Kate’s picture foreshadows what lies ahead. We’ll soon struggle to discern truth from lies. That will be corrosive - not just for individual societies, but human civilisation. If reality is malleable, if we cannot distinguish between fact and fiction, then we’re in serious trouble.

In an era of deep-fakes, nothing will be true. Genuine images will become as doubted as the manipulated. The evidence of your own eyes will be questioned, while lies take on the substance and power of truth. We need to fear this.

Essentially, then, this is a nothing-story which reveals a whole lot about the strange lineaments of the modern world.

Most of all, though, there’s a human being at the heart of it all. Kate may be a princess, and I’ve certainly no respect for princesses or princes or kings and queens. But I do have respect for the common heart, the soul, that we all share as human beings. And the human heart and soul are weak, fragile. We do foolish things to protect them, because we know they can be devoured in moments by the cruel and thoughtless appetites of others.

QOSHE - Neil Mackay: Saga of Catherine’s doctored photo reveals dark truths about our society - Neil Mackay
menu_open
Columnists Actual . Favourites . Archive
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close
Aa Aa Aa
- A +

Neil Mackay: Saga of Catherine’s doctored photo reveals dark truths about our society

3 5
14.03.2024

BACK in the deep past, it’s thought our ancient ancestors consumed kings and queens, literally ate them, probably after death. At the root of this ‘regiphagy’ there likely lay some strange belief that royal power could be transferred through an act of cannibalism.

We clearly haven’t changed very much, given the disturbing way British society is wolfing down the story of Catherine, Princess of Wales and her photoshopped pictures.

Once again, as a republican, I find myself feeling sympathy for a royal. I don’t hate the individuals in the royal family, I hate the institution. The royals themselves are human beings like you and I; they feel the same pain and shame we do. So, it’s hard not to empathise with Kate, pilloried and mocked as she is now, a million times a minute on social media across the world.

In a way, this is a nothing-story. A celebrity - for what’s royalty but the final rung on the showbiz ladder - photoshopped a picture. Big deal. Who cares?

Let’s try to exercise some empathy and consider why Kate might have edited the image. She’s a woman whose every move is studied like a specimen under a microscope. She was ill and underwent an operation. She then came under intense scrutiny for not being in the public eye. Soon, most of Britain was making jokes about her ‘disappearance’.

Catherine, Princess of Wales lives her life in the public eye (Image: free)

I’m trying hard not to be too po-faced here. The jokes were funny. I made some too. But unlike Kate, I wasn’t sitting at home - albeit that home is a palace - and reading this stuff.

Nor was all of it funny, or intended to be funny. Some........

© Herald Scotland


Get it on Google Play