Get unlimited access to everything VICE has to offer.

Turn off all ads on VICE.com

Exclusive New VICE Documentaries

Member Exclusive Features & Columns

Turn off all ads on VICE.com

Exclusive New VICE Documentaries

Member Exclusive Features & Columns

Turn off all ads on VICE.com

Exclusive New VICE Documentaries

Member Exclusive Features & Columns

4 Magazines Delivered to Your Door

What Your Pet Parenting Style Says About You (One Is Ruining Your Bond)

Share on X (Opens in new window)X

Share on Facebook (Opens in new window)Facebook

Share using Native toolsShareCopied to clipboard

Some people call their dogs their fur babies, while others won’t even let them near the couch. Most pet owners land somewhere in between. The way people live with their animals usually follows a “parenting” pattern, whether they’ve ever stopped to think about it or not.

When you spend enough time around other people’s pets, you’ll notice fairly quickly what side of the spectrum they’re on. One person has a dog with a bedtime routine, custom treats, and better healthcare than most adults. Another has a cat that runs the apartment like a tiny, unappointed dictator. Then there’s the owner who scolds and corrects every little thing, because they’re just an “animal” and need to obey. Of course, everyone thinks their own system is the reasonable one.

According to research discussed in Psychology Today, pet owners usually fall into recognizable parenting styles, similar to those used to describe raising kids. The framework is pretty simple. How much are you expecting from your pet, and how well are you responding to what they need?

What’s Your Pet Parenting Style?

One approach is very correction-focused. This is the owner who’s always saying “no,” always stepping in, always trying to shut behavior down the second it starts. The dog pulls on the leash, they raise their voice. The cat scratches the couch, someone reaches for the spray bottle. It might feel effective in the moment, but punishment-based methods have been linked to fear, stress, and a worse relationship between humans and animals.

Then you’ve got the opposite problem. Some people hand over the keys completely. A dog jumps on guests, steals food, loses its mind on walks, and somehow that’s supposed to be part of his charm. Or a cat bites, swats, shreds the blinds, and the owner says that’s just what sassy cats do. That style can come out of love, but it can also leave an animal undertrained, overstimulated, or unsure of what’s expected.

The better lane tends to be a balance of warmth plus structure. You use positive reinforcement. You learn your pet’s signals. You give them consistency, exercise, enrichment, and choices when it makes sense. You become more curious about what the “bad” behavior actually signals.

When people use a steadier, more responsive approach, dogs generally seem to benefit from it. Studies have linked that style to stronger attachment and better social behavior. The cat data is a little less clear-cut because cats insist on being difficult even in research, but the overall point still comes through. The way you handle life with your pet sets the tone for a lot of what follows.

This stuff gets built little by little. In the routines, the reactions, the rules, and the moments you barely think about at all. So if life with your pet feels harder than it needs to, it might be worth asking what your animal has been learning from the version of you they get every day.

Share on X (Opens in new window)X

Share on Facebook (Opens in new window)Facebook

Share using Native toolsShareCopied to clipboard

Photo: Robert Daly / Getty Images What Your Pet Parenting Style Says About You (One Is Ruining Your Bond) 2 minutes ago By Ashley Fike

What Your Pet Parenting Style Says About You (One Is Ruining Your Bond)

Photo: Belitas / Getty Images Simple Ways to Trigger Your Brain’s Happy Chemicals (Without Doing Something Illegal) 32 minutes ago By Sammi Caramela

Simple Ways to Trigger Your Brain’s Happy Chemicals (Without Doing Something Illegal)

Photo: PixelsEffect / Getty Images When Did ‘Working on Yourself’ Become a Full-Time Job? 1 hour ago By Sammi Caramela

When Did ‘Working on Yourself’ Become a Full-Time Job?

Photo: SolStock / Getty Images Scientists Just Found Even More Ways Vaping Can Kill You 2 hours ago By Luis Prada

Scientists Just Found Even More Ways Vaping Can Kill You

Photo by Buda Mendes/Getty Images How This Mega Pop Star Got Her ‘Big Break,’ Despite Not Even Wanting to Be a Singer 2 hours ago By Stephen Andrew Galiher

How This Mega Pop Star Got Her ‘Big Break,’ Despite Not Even Wanting to Be a Singer

By Stephen Andrew Galiher

Photo: Carol Yepes / Getty Images This Is the Age Your Happiness Will Hit a Low Point (and What to Do About It) 2 hours ago By Ashley Fike

This Is the Age Your Happiness Will Hit a Low Point (and What to Do About It)

Photo: FilippoBacci / Getty Images Caffeine Has a Strange Effect on Your Memory 3 hours ago By Luis Prada

Caffeine Has a Strange Effect on Your Memory

Photo: MangoStar_Studio / Getty Images 3 Signs You’re Stuck in a ‘Why Me?’ Mindset (and How I Broke the Habit) 3 hours ago By Sammi Caramela

3 Signs You’re Stuck in a ‘Why Me?’ Mindset (and How I Broke the Habit)

Photo: suteishi / Getty Images Intelligence Gap Relationships: Are You the Smart One or the Dumb One? 4 hours ago By Ashley Fike

Intelligence Gap Relationships: Are You the Smart One or the Dumb One?

Photo: DKart / Getty Images The Invasive Species Devouring North American and European Forests 4 hours ago By Luis Prada

The Invasive Species Devouring North American and European Forests

Kill the ads for just $2 a month

VICE membership also gives you access to our very best writing and exclusive new documentaries.

Add your account details

© Vice