Rethinking the Early History of North America
Forgot Your Password?
New to The Nation? Subscribe
Print subscriber? Activate your online access
.nation-small__b{fill:#fff;}
Rethinking the early history of North America
Rethinking the Early History of North America
Peter Mancall’s new book reframes the history of the American continent as a zone of encounters between Native peoples, European empires, and African societies.
On October 12, 1992, the commemorations for the 500th anniversary of Columbus’s landfall were uneven. Urban gatherings were moderately sized, but the mood was often less than celebratory. In Columbus, Ohio, the city’s $95 million floral and garden exposition drew roughly half the expected number of visitors. In Berkeley, California, the city defiantly reclaimed the date as Indigenous People’s Day, while in Nevada, an antinuclear gathering took place at a US Department of Energy test site, co-organized by Western Shoshone activists. Few festive events marked the quincentenary; fewer still generated national attention. By contrast, a century earlier, the 400th anniversary of Columbus’s arrival served as an occasion to celebrate—so much so that one of the country’s largest fairs ever was held in its honor, Chicago’s Columbian Exposition. But not so in 1992, when Columbus Day largely came and went.
Another date that has seen a dramatic shift in how it has been memorialized is 1776. Synonymous with the founding of the United States, 1776 has been treated by generations of Americans as part of a broader civilizational story: the westward expansion of European peoples, institutions, and political traditions. Within that framework, national commemorations form essential chapters in a single narrative linking European arrival to nationhood, thus blurring the distinction between the history of Europeans in what would become North America and the history of the United States itself.
Contested Continent: The Struggle for North America, c. 1000-1680
But over the past 40 or so years, a remarkable shift has occurred. More recent interpretations attempt to disentangle the history of colonization from that of the US Constitution. In this view, the United States is understood less as the political expression of European settlement than as a particular constitutional project: one grounded in republican government, in the institutions and philosophies articulated in the Declaration and then codified in the Constitution. Such interpretations do not deny the centrality of European colonization to the nation; rather, they critically reexamine North American and US history to foreground the peoples excluded, displaced, or subordinated by it. Native nations, enslaved Africans, and non-Anglo populations claimed as well as rejected the United States. In this interpretive framework, the history of the United States is not reducible to the history of Europeans in North America, even if European settlement formed its precondition.
The 12-hour PBS series The American Revolution reflects this interpretive shift. Its opening episodes foreground historians of Native America, seeking to widen the traditional narrative beyond a familiar story of colonial resistance to Britain. In doing so, the series implicitly asks whether 1776 should be remembered primarily as the triumph of a particular people in its struggle toward self-government, or as the beginning of a contingent experiment in such government. With more than half a dozen historians of Native America foregrounding the latter, the series details how the republic was founded, witnessed, and carried forward by a range of peoples and perspectives—peoples and perspectives that became more diverse with continental expansion.
Into this interpretive fray comes the latest offering in the venerable Oxford History of the United States, a now 10-volume series that, in the words of its publisher, “blends social, political, economic, cultural, diplomatic, and military history into coherent and vividly written narrative.” Initiated under the coeditorship of C. Vann Woodward and Richard Hofstadter in the 1960s, the series has become in many ways the Cadillac of US historical production: tomes written by master craftsmen without a female or minority author among them (yet). The books are not necessarily flashy but instead reflect the boxy and somewhat stodgy assumptions of the postwar historiography from which the series was born: sweeping national narratives organized around the development of the United States as a political, constitutional, and national project.
Peter Mancall’s Contested Continent joins these celebrated studies while also subtly unsettling the framework on which the series was built. Covering the period from 1000 to 1680, Mancall’s book offers the broadest chronological and geographic coverage of any of the volumes to date, stretching across a vast Atlantic world that encompasses Native peoples, European empires, African societies, and the unstable zones of encounter connecting them. Rather than treating the United States as the inevitable center of the narrative, Mancall uses these landscapes to frame a history in continental rather than national terms: a far-reaching “struggle for North America.”
That shift in scale and perspective mirrors the broader changes in historical interpretation that are now shaping commemorative debates. Earlier volumes in the series generally operated within the gravitational pull of the nation-state. Their organizing assumption was that US history could be narrated as the development of a single political society that moved, however unevenly and even hypocritically, toward national consolidation. Mancall’s study instead reflects the growing influence of Atlantic history, Native history, and borderlands scholarship, all of which have challenged nation-centered narratives. Such studies emphasize movement, contingency, competing sovereignty, and the permeability of imperial borders. The result is a history less concerned with national origins than with the larger continental and imperial processes out of which the United States emerged.
In so doing, Mancall draws on a remarkable range of sources, an impressive command of the field, and a clear........
