The Unpardonable Malpractice of Pete Hegseth
Forgot Your Password?
New to The Nation? Subscribe
Print subscriber? Activate your online access
.nation-small__b{fill:#fff;}
The Unpardonable Malpractice of Pete Hegseth
Yes, the defense secretary has committed impeachable offenses. But he’s also just really, really, really bad at his job.
The offenses cited by Representative Thomas Massie (R-KY) in commencing impeachment proceedings against Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth—that he initiated and sustained the war with Iran without required congressional approval, conducted military operations in Yemen and the Caribbean without such approval, and eroded protections for civilians trapped in overseas war zones—are all valid and fully justify his removal from office in accordance with constitutional precepts. But however worthy, they fail to capture his essential, unpardonable offense: strategic malpractice when commanding troops in battle.
Hegseth himself has been very outspoken about the need to cleanse the armed services of incompetent generals and admirals (many of whom, he claims, received their promotions as the result of some sort of affirmative action process) and to retain only those able to fight and win. “The previous administration wanted politically correct generals,” he told an assembly of junior officers on September 30. “We only want the top performing generals. It’s not just pass or fail…. The best move on, the worst do not.”
Secretary Hegseth wants us (and every member of Congress) to believe that he ranks among the successful generals and so should be retained. After berating Massie (“a disgruntled and defeated congressman”) and others during his unapologetic Pentagon press conference on November 10, Hegseth sought to defend his record as the ultimate commander of US forces. “By every measure,” he said of the war against Iran, “we achieved a historic military victory.”
But this is sheer fabrication. Were Hegseth to hold himself to the same high standards he supposedly set for his generals, he would have to say: “By every measure, we achieved a total fiasco in Iran,” and hand in his resignation.
To fully appreciate the magnitude of Hegseth’s incompetence, let’s recall the tasks he was assigned when ordered by President Trump to commence hostilities against Iran on February 28. As indicated by Trump in a prerecorded video address that morning, Hegseth was given four overriding objectives: (1) to eliminate, forever, Iran’s ability to construct a nuclear weapon; (2) to eliminate Iran’s ability to manufacture and launch long-range ballistic missiles; (3) to eliminate Iran’s ability to project power in the region, whether with its own military or via proxy forces like Hezbollah and the Houthi rebels; and (4) to eliminate the Iran problem altogether, by killing off Iran’s top leadership and igniting a popular rebellion.
Hegseth set out to achieve these goals with unrestrained vigor. The US military alone struck 13,000 targets in Iran during the first 38 days of fighting, and its Israeli partners struck many thousands more. From the administration’s perspective, it was a total win. In a press statement released on April 8, following the announcement of a ceasefire (that was to prove temporary), the White House declared that “the greatest fighting force the world has ever known has met those objectives with overwhelming strength and lethal precision.”
Among the war’s ostensible accomplishments: “Iran’s ballistic missile arsenal and production capacity has been razed…eliminating its ability to project power.” Also, “Iran can no longer arm terrorist proxies.” And, although the regime was still clinging to power: “What’s left of [it] is desperate, dejected, and in denial.”
For Hegseth, this was a “decisive military victory.”
But, in fact, it wasn’t: Not one of Trump’s stated objectives was achieved by Hegseth and the forces under his command. Not one.
To begin with, the Iranian regime has remained intact and (so far as can be determined from afar) remains as entrenched as ever, with no signs of an imminent popular rebellion.
Although the Iranians have made no visible move to reconstitute their uranium enrichment program (a prerequisite for manufacturing a nuclear bomb), they have demonstrated no inclination to surrender their existing stockpiles of highly enriched uranium or to renounce their enrichment efforts entirely.
And Iran’s regional clout—now buttressed by its apparent capacity to disrupt the Persian Gulf oil........
