As Pakistan once again drifts into constitutional speculation with talk of a possible 28th Amendment, the debate over new provinces has resurfaced with familiar urgency. Nearly a decade and a half after the 18th Amendment promised a decisive break from hyper-centralisation, the federal question remains unsettled. The issue is not merely administrative; it goes to the heart of how autonomy, identity, and stability are negotiated in the Pakistani state.

Historically, Pakistan’s experience with federalism has been defined by reluctance rather than accommodation. From the One Unit experiment to the dissolution of elected provincial assemblies in the 1970s, and from prolonged military rule to civilian governments operating under severe institutional constraints, decentralisation has been treated as a concession rather than an entrenched principle. Even the 1973 Constitution, despite its federal promise, was repeatedly undermined by executive interventions and centralised governance.

'Game Over' Narrative Dead: Laptops are state's investment in youth dreams, says Syeda Amnah Batool

The 18th Amendment in 2010 marked a structural rupture in this trajectory. By abolishing the Concurrent List, enhancing provincial autonomy, and recalibrating revenue sharing, it created political space for long-suppressed sub-national claims. Demands for new provinces emerged not in isolation, but as a logical consequence of devolved authority. Yet the translation of constitutional intent into political reality has remained uneven and contested.

Any serious discussion of new provinces must begin with the constitutional procedure itself. Article 239(4) of the Constitution of Pakistan stipulates that altering the boundaries of a province requires a two-thirds majority in the National Assembly, the Senate, and the concerned Provincial Assembly (or Assemblies). This is an exceptionally high threshold, designed to ensure broad-based consensus rather than majoritarian impulse. In practice, it gives effective veto power to dominant parties within provinces, particularly those that control provincial legislatures.

Rupee gains........

© The Nation