menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

It’s Time for Democrats to Put Up or Shut Up on Abortion Rights

6 0
tuesday

Sign up for the Slatest to get the most insightful analysis, criticism, and advice out there, delivered to your inbox daily.

A historic blue wave has raised questions about what Democrats will do with their majority in both houses of Congress. With a Republican president in office, there will be limits on what the new congressional majority can accomplish, not least on reproductive rights. But there are opportunities for the party to make progress before 2029 if Democrats use their power with purpose.

Pundits sometimes suggest that voters have moved past the abortion issue, even though data suggest that reproductive rights were a key issue for some voters. The truth is far more complicated. A network of shield laws ensures that abortion remains broadly available, even in states that criminalize it. Voters perhaps paid less attention to abortion this cycle because no major policy change was making headlines, but ballot initiatives protecting abortion rights—three of four of which were successful this fall—show voters still care. And reproductive rights remain under threat. The Trump administration may act to end telehealth access to medication abortion by March 2027; federal lawsuits filed by the attorneys general of Louisiana, Idaho and Missouri, and Texas and Florida seek to take abortion pills off the market or reimpose restrictions that the Food and Drug Administration lifted. Other challenges to shield laws are in the pipeline, some of them predicated on the Comstock Act, a 19th-century obscenity law that some conservatives interpret as a de facto national abortion ban.

Reproductive-rights policies have featured prominently in Democrats’ plans for the first 100 days of a new Congress, and if the party doesn’t act on that agenda, Democrats could fall into a familiar trap: waiting to act until there’s a conservative victory in the federal courts or anti-abortion action by the executive branch. Democrats have done this in the past, missing opportunities to pass landmark legislation in the Clinton and Obama administrations. With the dust settling on the midterm, Democrats should ensure that history does not repeat itself.

Skeptics will stress that Donald Trump is still in the White House. The president will likely veto most bills passed by the Democratic majority, which will fall well short of the two-thirds needed to override.

But Trump hardly seems passionate about reproductive issues, and it’s possible to imagine him signing a bill that goes some way to loosen abortion restrictions. Last year, for example, he suggested that the party should be open to changing the Hyde Amendment, which bars most Medicaid reimbursement for abortion—a statement that has increasingly worried abortion opponents. And Medicaid coverage matters a great deal.........

© Slate