menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Why turkey supply stays tight long after a bird flu outbreak ends

4 0
yesterday

Get Quartz in your inbox

Free daily briefing on global business news.

Privacy and Cookie Settings

Why turkey supply stays tight long after a bird flu outbreak ends

Bird flu turkey prices still reflect the 2022 H5N1 wave, from flock culls and slow rebuilding to biosecurity costs and holiday discounting at the grocery store

A turkey on a holiday table can carry the cost of disease that hit barns months earlier. Supply lost to an outbreak in one season can still be missing when shoppers buy birds in another. That lag is one reason bird flu turkey prices remain a live question long after any single outbreak is contained.

The current wave of highly pathogenic avian influenza, the H5N1 strain known as clade 2.3.4.4b, reached U.S. commercial poultry in February 2022. The first confirmed commercial flock was a turkey farm in Indiana. Outbreaks in commercial flocks continued through the rest of that year. Each new detection on a commercial farm sets off the same chain of events.

The path from a sick barn to a grocery receipt runs through several channels. Turkeys are highly susceptible to the virus, and infection can move through a flock quickly. A confirmed case on a commercial farm leads to the culling of the entire flock. Those birds never reach market. The barn must then be cleaned, disinfected and tested before new poults arrive. Those young birds then need months to grow to market weight.

Costs build up even on farms the virus never reaches. Producers have tightened controls on workers, vehicles and equipment to keep out virus carried by wild birds. Those measures add to production expenses. Federal indemnity payments from the U.S. Department of Agriculture help offset losses for farmers whose birds are destroyed. They cannot give back a lost selling season.

Bird flu is not the only disease in the picture. Avian metapneumovirus, a separate respiratory illness of turkeys, was confirmed in U.S. flocks in 2024. It adds its own pressure on output.

Geography matters too. Minnesota is the largest turkey-producing state, so outbreaks there carry more weight for national supply than those in smaller producing states. North Carolina and Arkansas are also major producers.

The shelf price adds another layer. USDA tracks wholesale turkey prices, but grocers often discount whole birds heavily as a holiday draw. Swings in the wholesale market therefore do not pass straight through to shoppers.

The 10 slides that follow are a selection of the factors linking avian influenza to turkey supply and cost. Each covers one mechanism, from the first 2022 detection to the annual Thanksgiving dinner cost survey from the American Farm Bureau Federation.

How H5N1 first reached U.S. commercial turkey flocks in 2022

The current bird flu wave in U.S. poultry began in a turkey barn. In February 2022, highly pathogenic avian influenza was confirmed in a commercial turkey flock in Dubois County, Indiana. That was the first confirmed case in a U.S. commercial flock in this wave.

The virus behind that detection is H5N1. Its name refers to two proteins on the virus surface, hemagglutinin and neuraminidase. The letters and numbers identify which subtype of each protein the virus carries.

Within H5N1, this virus belongs to a lineage designated clade 2.3.4.4b. A clade is a group of related viruses that share a common genetic ancestor. Each added level in the label marks a narrower branch of the H5 family tree. The label lets scientists and regulators tell one H5N1 lineage from another.

Highly pathogenic avian influenza is a formal classification, not a casual description. It covers strains that cause severe disease and high death rates in poultry, as judged by laboratory testing. Low pathogenic strains typically cause mild illness or none at all.

The highly pathogenic form is a reportable disease in the U.S. A suspected case on a farm must be reported to animal health authorities. USDA's Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service tracks and publishes confirmed detections in commercial flocks.

Dubois County sits in southern Indiana. The farm there is part of this wave's history because it was where the virus first surfaced in commercial production.

The Indiana case did not stay isolated. Outbreaks in commercial poultry continued through the rest of 2022. One confirmed flock became the first of a sustained run of detections.

For turkey costs, the starting point matters. The wave appeared in a turkey flock first, so turkey production was part of the story from the first confirmed commercial case. At no point did this wave touch only other kinds of poultry.

The February 2022 date also offers a fixed reference. Supply shifts, farm practices and price movements in later years trace back to a virus first confirmed on one Indiana farm that winter.

Why turkeys are especially vulnerable to avian influenza

Turkeys are highly susceptible to avian influenza. Once the virus reaches a turkey flock, it tends to spread fast and kill many birds. That is why a single detection can put an entire barn of turkeys at risk.

The strain behind the current outbreaks is classed as highly pathogenic avian influenza. In veterinary terms, "highly pathogenic" describes a virus that causes severe disease and high death rates in domestic poultry. The label refers to the virus's effect on birds, not its risk to people.

Wild waterfowl such as ducks and geese are the natural hosts of avian influenza viruses. Some wild ducks can carry the virus while showing few signs of illness. They shed it in their droppings as they travel along migratory flyways. Domestic turkeys do not share that tolerance.

Commercial turkeys are raised indoors, with large numbers of birds housed together in a single barn. The flock shares the same air,........

© Quartz