menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Does Banning Phones in School Boost Test Scores?

13 0
yesterday

Why Education Is Important

Find a Child Therapist

One large study found modest academic gains in schools with strict, all-day phone bans.

Repeatedly resisting the urge to check a phone may consume attention needed for learning.

Reading comprehension depends on recognizing misunderstandings and taking time to repair them.

Removing phones from classrooms may give students more opportunities to persist through difficult tasks.

You might know a child who can read every word in a paragraph but still not know what it means. Maybe she misunderstood why a character left their home, or why two people were talking in a certain conversation. She might keep reading until she stops understanding and realizes that she does. She might go back to find what she’s done wrong, or she might keep going. At the end of the page, she might have no idea what she’d actually read.

In my work as a speech pathologist, I’ve studied that type of breakdown for many years. When readers notice their mistakes, they might return to the earlier pages or rethink what they initially thought. But they have to hold the earlier information in mind. They have to have gaps where they can start to think about it and process. Those gaps take sustained attention and time. I’ve written about what happens in those gaps as productive uncertainty, the quality of sitting with and wrestling with questions.

I was thinking about those gaps in the context of two large studies on school phone bans that were released this year. The studies examined whether students score higher on tests when they have no phones available. One study suggested that they do, but only by a small margin. The other suggested that the scores hardly improve.

While this data are important, I’m more interested in how the process of learning shifts when students are less interrupted by phones. A phone within reach asks a child to keep deciding not to look at it, and each of these decisions draws on the attention she needs for the page.

Locking Phones Away Removes........

© Psychology Today