I vividly remember the episode that Attack on Titan lost me.

It wasn't the controversial ending where Eren Yeager became one of anime's most divisive protagonists. It wasn't even the basement reveal that changed everything. It was the moment Rod Reiss dropped to the ground and licked cerebrospinal fluid off an icy crystal cave floor littered with broken glass. Then he transformed into this big nasty malformed kaiju thing that could only crawl as it dragged its guts and exposed skull on the ground.

For fans of the series, that scene was just another stop in Attack on Titan's relentless march toward bigger and more complex ideas. For me, it was the moment I realized I wasn't watching the same show anymore. It had transformed from one of anime’s most intriguing survival horror stories into just another magical spectacle bogged down by its own lore.

When I first discovered Attack on Titan on Netflix over a decade ago, I was so hooked that I distinctly remember faking a headache so I could go to bed early, curl up with my phone, and squeeze in another episode before falling asleep. Its starting premise remains one of the greatest hooks in anime history.

Humanity huddles behind enormous walls while grotesque, naked giants roam the countryside devouring anyone unlucky enough to cross their path. Every expedition beyond the walls feels like a suicide mission. Named characters die horrific, unceremonious deaths. You feel it in your gut: They aren’t just eaten, they are devoured. Nobody is safe. Watching early Attack on Titan felt like seeing Game of Thrones in its prime.

Part of what makes the Titans so compelling and terrifying in the earlier seasons is that they're unknowable. Where did they come from? Why do they eat people? Why are they all naked with Barbie doll privates? When Eren suddenly develops the ability to generate a special Titan body he can control from inside, it feels like a total anomaly in this dark world — and like the key........

© Polygon