Revisiting legal and historical case of Junagadh
The question of Junagadh remains one of the unresolved territorial and constitutional disputes arising from the Partition of British India in 1947. While the Jammu and Kashmir dispute has received considerable international attention, the case of Junagadh has largely remained outside the mainstream international debate. Nevertheless, its historical circumstances raise important questions about the legal rights of princely states, the principles governing accession and the right of people to determine their political future.The princely State of Junagadh, situated in the Kathiawar Peninsula of present-day Gujarat, had its own ruler, administration and established political identity before Partition. Under the Indian Independence Act 1947, British paramountcy over the princely states lapsed, allowing their rulers to decide whether to accede to India or Pakistan. The legal framework did not expressly restrict this choice to geographical contiguity, although geographical, economic and administrative considerations were politically significant. On 14 September 1947, Nawab Mahabat Khanji III signed the Instrument of Accession, formally acceding Junagadh to Pakistan. Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah, Governor-General of Pakistan, accepted the Instrument on 15 September 1947. The accession was therefore formally executed and accepted under the constitutional arrangements then applicable to the princely states. The document remains central to Pakistan’s........
