menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

‘It’s not a lie if you believe it’: The Seinfeld solution to save Australian cricket

13 0
latest

‘It’s not a lie if you believe it’: The Seinfeld solution to save Australian cricket

November 22, 2026 — 2:00am

You have reached your maximum number of saved items.

Remove items from your saved list to add more.

No gift articles left

You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.

Simon Longstaff is the head of The Ethics Centre, which conducted a review into the culture of Australian cricket after the initial sandpaper scandal at Cape Town in 2018.

Fitz: I want to get to the cricket, Simon, but I think that as a matter of ethics, we should disclose that you and I are friends and were boarders together at Knox Grammar School in the 1970s, so know each other very well.

SL: We should indeed.

Fitz: But I don’t ever remember looking at you and thinking, “Now there’s a bloke who’s going to go on and lead the Ethics Centre and be a byword across Australia for integrity.”

SL: I’ve never pretended to be that! My feet are as much made of clay as anyone else’s.

Fitz: You will recall that the two major forces at Knox in the ’70s encouraging us to honesty were the Reverend Jim Donaldson and the disciplinarian Jock McConnell with the swishing cane? Did either of them make a big impact on you?

SL: Absolutely. I was occasionally – if unjustly – beaten with the cane.

Fitz: And did that help lead you to your current role?

SL: No, it was something far more profound that happened when I was seven. It lay in the death of my mother, because of her Roman Catholic beliefs. She felt she had to continue with a pregnancy, even after being told she and the baby would die if she didn’t terminate. She felt the child needed to be born and baptised to avoid (the now discredited state of) limbo, and so she went ahead with it. And a year and a day after giving birth, she did die, as predicted. But my brother Angus lived, and look … when you’re a seven-year-old and you wonder about how things like that can happen, it can get you thinking about the world, the way it works, and the way it should work.

Sandpapergate has gone from a mere crisis to an existential threat

Peter FitzSimonsColumnist and author

Fitz: I … you … um … I’m very sorry to hear such a story. Moving on, you must have a good definition of ethics. Something from Edmund Burke, perhaps?

SL: Much older. It goes back to Socrates. It’s derived from the idea that the unexamined life is not worth living. So, unlike simple morality – where you can apply values and principles as a matter of habit – to live an ethical life is to live a life that’s examined, a life of reflective practice.

Fitz: OK, so let us then reflect on the situation in cricket. There’s a brilliant piece in the Herald this week – as a matter of fact, I wrote it – noting that, by and large, train smashes are prettier than this current mess. Do you agree?

SL: Absolutely. And the reason I think so is that the initial wrong inherent in the conduct that took place in South Africa is now made significantly worse, through the near-iron law of history that the cover-up does more damage than the original sin.

Cheating won’t bring down Australian cricket. Lying about cheating will

Malcolm KnoxJournalist, author and columnist

Journalist, author and columnist

Fitz: Prima facie, the whole thing feels like the exemplar of the colossal damage that can be done by straying from ethical behaviour, and that progressively lower........

© WA Today