Pens Are Not Swords
Last week in Islamabad, an educated, affluent lady dismissed every writer in the room: ‘We don’t want narratives; we want action. These essays solve nothing.’ Her impatience deserves an answer, not a defence: action without direction is force without purpose, and the demand for action must first ask what action, by whom, and under what accountability. Overlooking that writing itself is an action, she left hurriedly — angry and unconvinced.
Every society, sooner or later, begins to look for a saviour.
When corruption becomes routine and injustice the norm, the gaze turns desperately to writers, intellectuals, and moral voices, as though a poet with a pen might also carry a sword. We half-expect them to confront every corrupt person in society.
But writers write. They do not take up swords. The writer’s task is to expose corruption, shape public conscience, and defend principles; enforcement belongs to institutions, leaders, and the rule of law.
This is not a small distinction. The roles of Allama Iqbal and Salahuddin Ayyubi must be kept apart. Iqbal awakened a sleeping conscience with ideas and verse; Salahuddin built armies, institutions, and a state. One stirred the soul; the other organised the world. Both were necessary; neither could substitute for the other. When a society confuses the two and waits for a thinker to do the work of a state, it does not honour its........
