An elegy of unbelonging
In a recent X post, I promised to share my thoughts on Sonia Gandhi's new memoir, Belonging, which has sparked intense debate across India and beyond. First, a few caveats on what this piece is not. It is neither a book review nor a critical audit. The analytical tools that usually serve me well in matters of politics and reason feel inadequate against such an unrelenting tide of raw emotion. Yet neither is this a hagiography. At the heart of the book lies an emotive core that shifts hue from sheer love to grief, bewilderment, and quiet acceptance. What follows, then, is a map of the emotions the book stirred in me. For your own emotional safety, I do not recommend reading this book. But if you must, read it for its emotional range and velocity, not for the subjectivity of the author's historical commentary.
Now to the book. The cover image first. Framed in vintage monochrome, a young Mrs Gandhi meets the camera with a steady, guarded gaze, dark waves falling past her shoulders. Her fingers curl softly beneath her chin, an index finger resting just below her lower lip, as if the young woman looking back has only just stopped chewing her nails in nervousness. Had this book pretended to be anything more than an honest emotional chronicle of a life in the public eye, we would have seen present-day Mrs Gandhi sitting behind a wooden desk, signing important-looking documents under a title like 'My Struggle' or 'My Destiny'.
The title itself is the second giveaway. On the surface, belonging is a gerund, a verb serving as a noun. Yet it is the verb that caught me off guard here. We South Asians are accustomed to its passive use, as in 'I belong to my country', rather than its........
