menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

India’s tax rules need an overhaul, not knee-jerk changes

14 0
previous day

In retrospect, the headlines look bipolar. From market doom to boom, the news took just two weeks to flip. For the preceding two months, there was a concentrated campaign to remove taxes on both foreign and Indian equity. Newspaper headlines, TV shows, podcasts, reels and all kinds of social media posts made the case that foreign investors had abandoned India due to the higher tax incidence here versus other markets. The domestic SIP investor was gullible and was funding the FII exit. Unless these taxes were removed, the foreign money would never come back. And if these were removed for foreign, why not for Indian investors? But then, ‘never’ is a difficult word that does not age well. It took all of 11 trading days for the Indian stock market to recover what it had lost over the past eight months, with zero tax trigger.

India does need tax reform on investments, but knee-jerk policy reactions almost always end badly. If we begin from first principles, then the government has to be clear whether it wants to use tax policy to drive investments in a particular direction. That seems to have been the thought till now with tax deductions given on life and medical insurance, on pension products, on real estate investing and reinvesting and on some small savings products that funnel money directly to the government. The new tax regime has........

© hindustantimes