Prop. 40 Lost: The Fight Over a Wealth Tax Is Moving to Washington
California voters recently came together to reject Proposition 40, which would have imposed a one-time 5 percent tax on residents worth more than $1 billion and made California the first state to enact a wealth tax at the ballot box. The result is a win for taxpayers, but it doesn’t end the debate. The fight now moves to Washington, D.C. Prop. 40 was in trouble before a single ballot was cast. Several of the state’s wealthiest residents left ahead of the January 1 residency cutoff, taking tens of billions in projected revenue with them. Even Governor Gavin Newsom opposed the measure, warning that driving out California’s biggest taxpayers could leave the state with less revenue, not more.
Still, proponents were loud in the buildup to the midterm elections, continuing to sell Prop. 40 as a tax only a couple hundred people would ever pay. The data told a different story. California’s nonpartisan Legislative Analyst projected that ongoing income tax collections would fall as wealthy residents left, and Stanford’s Hoover Institution estimated the measure would cost the state roughly $25 billion over time. That gap would not have been covered by billionaires who had already moved to other states. It........
