menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Whole Hog Politics: How a little more ‘pearl clutching’ would have helped GOP

26 0
18.09.2026

Whole Hog Politics: How a little more ‘pearl clutching’ would have helped GOP

[Watch Whole Hog Politics Live: Hill Insider members can join us live today at 9 a.m. ET as Chris Stirewalt and host Bill Sammon go deep on this week’s political news. Members can join the discussion and pose their questions to Bill and Chris. Tune in!]

In the run-up to last fall’s state elections in Virginia and New Jersey, Democrats belatedly found a weapon to use against the barrage of GOP attacks on the blue team’s nominee for Virginia attorney general.

The episode understandably has faded from memory because, as it turned out, it was a meaningless spin cycle. Jay Jones, the candidate who had sent creepy, cruel texts to a Republican former statehouse colleague, won in a breeze. He came in a little more than 4 points behind the top of the ticket, but a big blue wave in both states carried all the Democratic candidates, good and bad, to victory.

For a moment in October, though, when polls suggested some uncertainty in that outcome, Republicans zeroed in on Jones — very progressive, inexperienced and running to be the first Black attorney general in the commonwealth’s history — as a way to frighten law-and-order suburbanites and to suggest the moderation expressed by Democrats was only a ruse to gain power.

Anxious Democrats breasted a great sigh of relief when the story of the Young Republican group chat broke loose. A former member of the group for Republicans under age 40 (young being a relative term) had leaked the messages with all manner of horrible stuff: racism, antisemitism, gay slurs and jokes about gas chambers, slavery and rape. And some of those involved were or had become staffers with official positions in the party.

Democratic spinmeisters had a way to reclaim the narrative about nasty electronic communications. Any question about Jones could be answered with an “Oh, yeah. How about your holocaust jokes?” Most Republicans confronted with the messages were quick to denounce and disavow them and their senders. But into this panic strode Vice President Vance, cool and collected, telling his fellow Republicans not to take the bait.

These “edgy, offensive jokes” told by “kids”  — “especially young boys” — who “do stupid things” should not “ruin their lives.” The most important thing, Vance said, was to keep the focus on Jones in Virginia: “I refuse to join the pearl clutching when powerful people call for political violence.”

But, of course, the question of whether to clutch or not to clutch was immaterial. The rout was on. Indeed, insofar as the question of which texts were worse mattered to any persuadable voter, a lack of pearl clutching may actually have hurt Republicans’ performance. If you were one of the many fiscally conservative, socially moderate suburbanites in Virginia or New Jersey concerned about the unsavory elements of the post-Jan. 6 GOP, it might have been comforting to hear party leaders take the chuds behind the rhetorical woodshed. 

Vance, though, made it clear that these 30-something-year-olds should be shielded to deny Democrats to deflect from Jones. But that’s not how campaign communications work. Refusing to condemn the Young Republicans leaders didn’t lessen attention to the scandal, but rather increased it. Ask any Democrat this year how well deflect-to-protect has worked with the initial efforts to “move on” from their own chud faction, especially Graham Platner and Hasan Piker. Vance imagined a stone wall, but instead provided a gate through which the story could charge ahead.

We can mostly leave aside how Vance’s personal ambitions may have interfered with the counsel he provided to his party. But it is fair to say that Vance launched his efforts to minimize the offense in an interview with Turning Point USA, the group for campus right-wingers founded by Charlie Kirk. Turning Point USA is a centerpiece of Vance’s 2028 campaign and is an important part of his bid to block any challenger from his right. He was presumably talking more to the very online, young, male podcast audience than any suburban moms in Leesburg, Va., or Parsippany, N.J. 

But, again, it probably didn’t matter much to the election results in those states what Vance said. The climate had already turned very cold for the Republicans, and swing voters were swinging hard back to the Democrats after a good year for the GOP in 2024. But that doesn’t mean Vance’s strategy didn’t have political consequences.

Remember that the Jones-Young Republicans imbroglio was before the Iran war, surging prices, steep mortgage rates, the massive personal paydays for President Trump and everything else that has afflicted the red team this year. The climate of a year ago looks positively balmy compared with what the GOP is facing now. 

In other words, now is not a good time for Republicans to again be debating the appropriateness of white nationalism, Nazi imagery, deeming oneself a “heritage American” and dealing........

© The Hill