Humans are biologically wired to seek connection through collective artistic experiences.

Cultural forms once dismissed—like jazz or rock—often become lasting generational touchstones.

Shared music and performance can synchronize breathing, heart rate, and emotional states.

During a recent press tour, Timothée Chalamet joked about ballet and opera: “Hey—keep this thing alive,” he said with a laugh, before adding that talking about them probably cost him “14 cents in viewership.”

The joke reflects a broader assumption about the performing arts: that they are beautiful but increasingly irrelevant in a world dominated by streaming and short-form entertainment. Far from being obsolete, shared artistic experiences may be one of the few remaining cultural spaces where we meet our need for connection.

As artists, educators, and advocates for the neuroarts, we understand the sentiment. From a market perspective, the performing arts can feel fragile. We live in an era of hyper-personalized streaming, AI-generated content, and algorithms designed to keep us scrolling individually. A three-hour opera or a traditional ballet can seem like a relic of a bygone age.

The Enduring Appeal of Shared Artistic Experiences

Why do Chalamet’s own films succeed? Why does The Nutcracker remain a blockbuster? The answer isn’t just good marketing or celebrity pull. We are wired for shared artistic experiences. Art is not just “content” to be consumed. It is the connective tissue of our shared history and part of how our nervous systems learn.

You’re not wrong, Timothée, but you may need to "get out of the cave" of modern digital consumption to see the light of what art actually does for the human species.

More than a century ago, the 1913 premiere of The Rite of Spring at the Théâtre des Champs-Élysées provided a perfect snapshot of this. Paris’ cultural elite expected refinement; instead, they were met with Vaslav Nijinsky’s jagged choreography and Igor Stravinsky’s pounding, primal rhythms. The audience didn’t just dislike it—they erupted. Accounts describe shouting, whistling, and actual physical confrontations.

From a neuroarts perspective, we see a community encountering something radically new together and reacting in real time. They weren’t processing it quietly and alone; they were responding collectively. Their nervous systems were being challenged, and they relied on one another to navigate that intensity.

The Biological Impact of Shared Experiences

When we experience music or dance in a group, our breathing and heart rates begin to synchronize. These shared experiences can stimulate the release of oxytocin—the "bonding hormone." The arts entertain us as they regulate our nervous systems and bridge the gap between "me" and "we."

Humans regulate emotion through shared experience. When we laugh in a theater, sing in a choir, or sit quietly with hundreds of strangers listening to the same melody, our nervous systems begin to align. Collective music experiences can lead to heart rate, breathing, and even subtle movements synchronizing across groups. These moments of shared rhythm create a powerful sense of belonging. Something increasingly rare in a culture built around individualized screens.

This cycle of dismissal, the idea that a genre is "dead" or "negative," is a recurring theme in cultural history. When jazz, country, soul, and rock and roll first emerged, they were met with similar skepticism. Many spoke out about the "negative influence" of rock and roll on teenagers, fearing it would unravel the fabric of society.

Those genres became the heartbeat of generations. We often fear what we don’t yet understand or dismiss what feels "old" or "foreign;" yet, these forms that sustain us over time. They survive because they offer a way to process the human condition.

We are currently living through a shift toward solitary consumption. We watch films on laptops, scroll through stories on Instagram, and experience the world through the blue light of our phones. As movie theaters close and streaming services make films instantly accessible from the couch in our pajamas, we are losing more than just "the Dolby experience." We are losing the magic of sitting in a dark room with strangers and feeling the same thing at the same time.

As we become increasingly involved in an AI-driven world, live performance becomes more valuable, not less. AI can mimic the structure of a song or the script of a play, but it cannot (yet) replicate the biological resonance of a live performer’s breath or the electricity of a crowd’s shared silence. We are social creatures craving connection in an age of digital alienation.

The Artist's Role in Society

Thousands of years ago, Plato envisioned that we expand our love by first recognizing beauty in one another. This is the ultimate role of the artist: to serve as a mirror, a bridge, and a lighthouse. The artist helps us see the beauty in the human experience, thereby expanding our capacity to love.

If we treat art forms like opera or ballet as "dead," we overlook the tools that help us be human. The burden isn't just on the audience; it’s on the institutions and the artists.

At Mozart for Munchkins, the interactive concert series Sara founded in New York City, we see this transformation daily. On a summer afternoon at Hudson Yards, toddlers and grandparents fall into a sudden, hushed silence as a soprano begins Puccini’s O Mio Bambino Caro. The space stilled. That aria belongs there just as much as the Broadway musicians from Hamilton who join the program later.

We don't create lifelong lovers of the arts by demanding reverence or "shushing" the uninitiated. We create them by breaking the fourth wall. We teach kids to clap on two and four for jazz, or to spin in circles to feel the tempo of Flight of the Bumblebee. That embodied experience—feeling the difference between forte and piano in one’s own body—is how memory forms.

Classical music, ballet, and opera were never meant to be silent or distant. During Mozart’s lifetime, audiences talked, cheered, and booed. It was a social, living experience. To "save" these art forms, we don't need to "mutilate" them to sell them; we simply need to make them accessible and human again.

An Invitation to Embrace Artistic Connection

So, Mr. Chalamet, instead of knocking an art form down, we invite you to join the revolution. The performing arts are not dying; they are waiting for us to put down our phones and remember what it feels like to be together.

In a world where AI shapes our tastes and streaming services curate our lives, the collective soul is found in the theater, the concert hall, and the town square. Art is what reminds us that we are not alone. It survives when people remember how it made them feel—and how it made them love.

We wish you well on your artistic journey. May you find the grace that comes when the lights go down and the shared heart of the audience begins to beat as one.

There was a problem adding your email address. Please try again.

By submitting your information you agree to the Psychology Today Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy

© Psychology Today