The Referendum Paradox
Military rulers, too, have repeatedly introduced local government systems, but often as instruments of political legitimacy rather than genuine democratic decentralisation.
The problem, therefore, is not simply the absence of local elections; it is the unwillingness to transfer meaningful administrative, political and financial authority to elected local representatives, as per the dictates of Article 140A of the Constitution of Pakistan, 1973.
The real test of democracy is not how frequently political parties invoke popular sovereignty, but how willing they are to share power with the people.
By Muhammad Imran, Staff Member, SAHSOL-LUMS Maria Batool, Law Graduate-2025, SAHSOL-LUMS
Pakistan’s history of referendums presents a curious constitutional paradox: an instrument designed to strengthen democracy has repeatedly been employed by military rulers to legitimise authoritarianism. Although Article 48 of the Constitution of 1973 recognises the referendum as a means of obtaining the people’s opinion on matters of national importance, its political application has remained far removed from its democratic purpose. Ironically, no elected civilian government has meaningfully employed this constitutional provision, while all three nationwide referendums in independent Pakistan were conducted under military dictators.
General Ayub Khan held the first referendum on Feb 14, 1960, using the Basic Democracies system as an electoral college rather than seeking a direct vote from the entire adult electorate. General Ziaul Haq followed on Dec 19, 1984, seeking endorsement of his Islamisation programme and securing a five-year presidential mandate. General Pervez Musharraf conducted the third referendum on April 30, 2002, to obtain public approval for his continuation as president for another five years. Despite their different political circumstances, all three exercises shared a common objective: consolidating the authority of the incumbent ruler.
The referendum, therefore, acquired a distinctly dictatorial legacy in Pakistan. Instead of allowing citizens to........
