With America’s 250th birthday as an independent nation coming up in 2026, the big debate on the right this season about what it means to be an American couldn’t be more timely.

Vice President JD Vance and Vivek Ramaswamy — the 2024 presidential aspirant who hopes to be elected Ohio governor next year — have both weighed in.

The two extremes in the debate are the “creedal nationalists,” who emphasize America as an idea, and those who boast of being “heritage Americans” with lineages in this country stretching back generations or centuries.

Aren’t long-established families — whose ancestors came over on the Mayflower or fought in the Revolutionary War — more American than relative newcomers?

Absolutely not, say those who insist America is about values, not bloodlines.

For creedal nationalists, an American is defined by belief “in the rule of law, in freedom of conscience and freedom of expression, in colorblind meritocracy, in the U.S. Constitution, in the American dream,” as Ramaswamy wrote in the New York Times Dec. 17.

Ramaswamy’s forebears came from India: Does that make him less American than the descendants of 17th-century English settlers?

The argument isn’t just about history; it’s about immigration today.

Not only does creedal nationalism suppose the country has nothing to fear from immigration on any scale — as long as new arrivals accept the patriotic catechism — it also implies those who oppose large-scale immigration anyway are really un-American.

Yet the creed........

© Independent Journal Review