menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Who Lost California?

13 0
30.10.2026

Way back in the early days of the Cold War, a partisan debate over American foreign policy boiled down to a simple question: Who lost China?                                                                                                                                       

For Democrats, then in control of both the White House and Congress, the matter was a source of embarrassment in that the world’s most populous nation had turned red (as in Communist, not conservative) after the defeat of the Nationalist Chinese forces who had been allies of the United States in World War II.

And for some Republicans, the fallout from what transpired on the other side of the Pacific Rim presented an opportunity to prey on the electorate’s jangled nerves (the Soviet Union detonating its first atomic bomb and the People’s Republic of China formally declared just thirty-three days apart in the fall of 1949). Thus, only four months after the rise of Red China, came the spectacle of Senator Joseph McCarthy claiming that the US State Department was riddled with “fellow travelers” complicit in the success of the Maoist regime.

In the America of 2026, a similar question can be asked on a matter of domestic politics: Who lost California?

Or, to put it differently: Who or what killed two-party competition in the Golden State?

It’s a fair question to ask on the eve of a November election that likely will see more of the same in California: after the votes are counted, Democrats in control of every statewide constitutional office, supermajorities in both chambers of the State Legislature and, thanks to a partisan gerrymandering scheme approved by voters last fall, only four of California’s fifty-two congressional seats occupied by a Republican.

Of course, this wasn’t the California of previous generations: a state that sent native son Richard Nixon and adoptive son Ronald Reagan to the White House and, throughout the twentieth century, elected fourteen Republican and only four Democratic governors.

So, who or what “lost” California and the notion of a healthy, two-party competition?

Let’s look at a few of the “usual subjects.”

Pete Wilson. The last Republican to win an “open” gubernatorial race in California (by a difference of less than 1.5 percent), Wilson would earn a second term in 1994 courtesy of a 14.5 percent landslide—a good year for Republicans in the Golden State as GOP candidates also prevailed in the contests for state attorney general, secretary of state, state insurance commissioner, and state treasurer (full disclosure: I served as Wilson’s chief speechwriter during his second term).

Why Wilson is considered a “suspect” by some: his steadfast support of 1994’s Proposition 187, which aimed to cut off certain public benefits (public education and health care) for........

© Hoover Institution