Greener pastures? Toby’s departure would be a disaster for the Giants

May 23, 2026 — 5:00am

You have reached your maximum number of saved items.

Remove items from your saved list to add more.

That Toby Greene is considering ending his decorated and colourful career away from Greater Western Sydney has placed an uncomfortable spotlight on the AFL’s youngest club, putting the Giants firmly at football’s crossroads.

To put it bluntly, the prospect of the GWS captain preferring a strong Victorian club over the outfit that bears his DNA would be a disaster for the Giants. After dedicating more than 15 years of blood, sweat, and tears to the club, choosing greener pastures for a premiership would be an alarm-bells moment and the continuum of a series of dominoes that began before the season started when the board delayed its decision on the future of chief executive Dave Matthews.

Greene, who turns 33 on the eve of the grand final, has never before let his contract talks move so close to the deadline which sees him an unrestricted free agent. He sounded the alarm last week when he spoke about his desire to move back to Melbourne – at some unspecified point – for family reasons, leaving his future at the Giants uncertain.

Then his favoured successor to the captaincy, Tom Green, chimed in on his now regular SEN radio segment, confirming his serious concerns about his beloved leader. The younger Green added that Toby Greene’s potential exit would underline his lack of belief in the Giants and their quest for a premiership during the time he has left.

Green comes out of contract next year and will be targeted by clubs Australia-wide and specifically Tasmania. His comments increased the decibels and should have resonated at the board table headed up by the club’s relatively new president, Tim Reed, who has made it clear he wants to make changes at the Giants. But his top-order priority should be moving swiftly to secure both Toby Greene and reigning club champion Green.

This, in turn, makes the choice of a replacement for the long-serving chief executive officer Dave Matthews critical. Reed appeared to have decided to appoint a new club boss after 16 years anyway, but Matthews’ decision to take his future into his own hands and pre-empt the board’s decision blindsided the president with its timing over Gather Round. Greene, who is close with Matthews, would now need to be comfortable with the club’s off-field direction before agreeing to commit to the Giants for his playing life.

Greene is the Giants’ games........

© Brisbane Times