menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Five Problems With The ‘Greenhouse Gas Trapping Heat’ Narrative

14 0
16.11.2026

Five Problems With The ‘Greenhouse Gas Trapping Heat’ Narrative

A closer look at atmospheric physics raises questions about the conventional explanation of greenhouse warming.

Douglas J. Cotton | November 16, 2026

For many years, government agencies, universities, and media organizations have told the public that greenhouse gases “trap heat” and thereby warm the Earth’s atmosphere and surface. The phrase has become so commonplace that few people stop to examine whether it is physically possible.

Yet once one considers the behavior of molecules in the atmosphere, the proposition becomes highly problematic. The atmosphere is not a collection of isolated greenhouse-gas molecules storing their own private stockpile of thermal energy. It is a highly interactive environment in which billions upon billions of collisions occur every second.

The following five points illustrate why the conventional description of greenhouse warming deserves much closer scrutiny.

1. Why Greenhouse Gases Cannot Store Significantly More Heat Than Surrounding Air

Consider the following basic facts:

Greenhouse gases comprise only a small fraction of the atmosphere.

Over 99% of the atmosphere consists of nitrogen, oxygen, and argon.

All atmospheric molecules are continually colliding with one another.

Molecular heat is simply kinetic energy associated with molecular motion.

Every greenhouse gas molecule is surrounded by thousands or even millions of non-greenhouse molecules.

Any increase in kinetic energy acquired by a greenhouse molecule is rapidly shared with neighboring molecules through collisions.

Likewise, greenhouse molecules continuously receive energy from surrounding air molecules.

Consequently, greenhouse gases cannot remain significantly hotter than nearby air molecules for any sustained period. Any temporary energy imbalance is continually reduced by collisions that transfer energy among molecules.

These graphics illustrates this process:

2. Collisions Equalise Molecular Kinetic Energy

The kinetic theory of gases has long explained why gases naturally move........

© American Thinker