menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

America’s Welfare State Nourishing Itself With Our Money

35 0
15.11.2026

America’s Welfare State Nourishing Itself With Our Money

A system designed to relieve hardship has become a sprawling industry with powerful incentives to perpetuate dependency.

Allan J. Feifer | November 15, 2026

Our Public Charges are parasites on the national body. The threat comes not just from the cost but from the growing and increasingly political constituency invested in their expansion. What begins as assistance becomes an entitlement, then an expectation, and eventually becomes enshrined throughout society. Once that occurs, the system develops powerful constituencies that benefit from its growth. For some progressives, this may be more than an unintended consequence. It may be part of the objective: dismantling the old order to make way for what comes next.

The definition of a Public Charge is “A person who depends, or could be reasonably expected to depend, on government assistance for their basic support.” Although primarily used in immigration law, the underlying concept has broader application. In America, dependency takes several forms, from citizens relying on welfare for basic subsistence to non-citizens receiving public support. There are degrees of dependency, of course. Receiving Medicaid or food assistance doesn’t necessarily make someone fundamentally dependent on government. But there is a difference between temporary assistance and making government support a way of life. Welfare once carried a stigma; today, dependency has become normalized for many.

Excluding Social Security, roughly 100 million Americans received at least one means-tested government benefit in 2019, according to HHS. That includes Medicaid, food assistance, housing subsidies, and direct cash payments. It doesn’t mean everyone depends on government for basic subsistence, but it demonstrates the scale of government involvement in people’s lives. Meanwhile, the federal income-tax burden is heavily concentrated: the top half of taxpayers paid 96.7% of federal individual income taxes in 2023.

The non-citizen population adds another dimension. Brookings estimates that approximately 22.8 million non-citizens lived in the United States in 2023, across 13.4 million households containing at least one non-citizen. Census research estimates that approximately 5.9 million had........

© American Thinker