menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Democrats made three big economic promises. They’ll need to break one.

44 0
11.11.2026

The context you need, when you need it

When news breaks, you need to understand what actually matters — and what to do about it. At Vox, our mission to help you make sense of the world has never been more vital. But we can’t do it on our own.

We rely on readers like you to fund our journalism. Will you support our work and become a Vox Member today?

Democrats made three big economic promises. They’ll need to break one.

The party won a mandate for an impossible agenda.

If you buy something from a Vox link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement.

The Democratic Party just won its largest congressional majorities in more than a decade. In the House specifically, if current vote tallies hold, it will boast more seats next year than at any time since 1992.

Now what do they do with that power?

In the near term, the extraordinary scale of the Democrats’ midterm victory might be of little consequence. So long as President Donald Trump holds veto power over legislation, a 254-seat House majority may be no better at advancing the Democratic agenda than a 218-seat one would be.

Democrats’ midterm landslide makes it likely that if they win the White House in 2028, they’ll also have comfortable congressional majorities to pass their economic agenda.

The party has promised to expand the welfare state, cut taxes for everyone but the rich, and bring down inflation and interest rates, but those goals will likely prove incompatible.

Taxing the rich alone probably can’t fund a massive new safety net, yet even this year’s unusually Democratic electorate rejected broader tax hikes.

To ease the tension between their priorities, Democrats should embrace policies that boost the economy’s productive capacity.

Two years from now, however, the blue tsunami’s size could matter enormously. Democrats are unlikely to do quite as well in the 2028 election as they did this year, when the Republican base largely abstained. But Democratic Senate leader Chuck Schumer’s party now has plenty of seats to spare. For this reason, if Democrats win the presidency in 2028, they are now extremely likely to also secure full control of Congress — and by comfortable margins.

This is no small thing. Under President Joe Biden, Democrats held only a bare Senate majority, enabling any individual senator to dictate the terms of their policymaking. A Democratic president has not had the chance to govern with robust congressional support since 2010.

Democrats are therefore within striking distance of a rare opportunity — a chance to enact their economic agenda without asking Republicans or their party’s most unreliable centrists for permission.

To seize this historic opening, Democrats will need to formulate a platform that effectively advances their core goals. Unfortunately, this will be harder than it sounds — because the party’s current economic priorities appear incompatible with each other.

During the midterm campaign, Democrats promised to:

• Bring down inflation and interest rates.

• Dramatically expand the welfare state.

• Raise taxes on the very wealthy — but no one else — while cutting taxes for millions of Americans.

Democrats have good reason for embracing all of these objectives. In the last three federal elections, voters punished incumbents for presiding over a rising cost of living. So any governing party would be eager to reduce inflation and borrowing costs, both of which continue to trend in the wrong direction.

“This was the biggest change election in any of our lifetimes,” Democratic Rep. Greg Casar, chair of the Congressional Progressive Caucus, told me. “And Americans are demanding that we take on these high prices, root out corruption, and make their lives better.”

Democrats’ desire to expand the welfare state is similarly understandable. Americans lack many forms of social insurance that are common in wealthier countries, such as truly universal healthcare.

Finally, the party’s embrace of middle-class tax cuts reflects the US electorate’s growing antipathy for taxation. Indeed, last Tuesday, a historically Democratic electorate voted to restrict or cut taxes in states across the country.

If Democrats’ goals are understandable, however, they aren’t necessarily coherent. In economic conditions similar to today’s, it probably won’t be possible to create large new social programs, avoid tax hikes on anyone but the rich, and drive down inflation and........

© Vox