An Analysis of the Film "You Can See Everything"
Apparent agreeableness can invite escalating intrusions rather than signal genuine consent.
Believing we uniquely understand someone can lead us to override their wishes and autonomy.
The film may reveal others’ appropriation of Holmes’s identity more than her authentic self.
In the trailer for "You Can See Everything," Nathan Fielder positions himself inches from Elizabeth Holmes’s face and asks whether she is telling the truth. Her eyebrows are raised, her eyes wide, and her smile eerily fixed. The expression is disturbing in isolation. But in the film, Fielder returns to the question of her honesty again and again, often at the same invasive distance. Holmes continues smiling and nodding, maintaining that she has never lied while offering remarkably little resistance to his relentless questioning. What initially looked like an unnatural expression begins to resemble an attempt to appease the man confronting her.
As a psychologist and author of the forthcoming book Being Seen, I was particularly interested in a documentary that promised such intimate access to one of the most scrutinized women in America. What interested me was how the people surrounding Holmes might influence what we actually get to see of her.
Why Is Holmes So Agreeable?
This is not a diagnosis, but Holmes’s persistent smile brings to mind fawning, a response in which someone attempts to appease a person they experience as threatening or overpowering. Rather than objecting or withdrawing, they become extremely agreeable, anticipate what the other person wants, and try to avoid further confrontation. Someone may continue smiling even when........
