menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

“Nothing like before” — China is out-competing the West on EVs 

5 0
05.01.2025

The West is accusing China of “overcapacity” to blame it for its own industrial demise.

The past year has seen a concerted effort by Western politicians, regime intellectuals, and media stenographers to accuse China of “overcapacity”. The coordinated narrative has accompanied a choreographed escalation in the West’s economic war on China.

For issue #107 of The Internationalist, Pawel Wargan, Political Coordinator of the Progressive International, looks at how the West is accusing China of “overcapacity” to blame it for its own industrial demise.

In May 2024, the White House announced a series of new tariffs on Chinese products, including a 100% tax on imports of Chinese electric vehicles (EVs), set to take effect later this year. The European Union followed closely behind. In July, the Commission announced duties ranging from 17.4% to 37.6% on Chinese EV manufacturers. And in August, Canada announced 100% tariffs on Chinese EVs along with 25% tariffs on Chinese steel and aluminium.

The White House insisted that the measures would “protect American manufacturers from China’s unfair trade practices” and ensure that “the future of the auto industry will be made in America by American workers.” The European Commission cited China’s “unfair subsidisation” and Canada warned of the threat of China’s “intentional, state-directed policy of overcapacity”. In this narrative, now choreographed and ritualised across the West, China’s “overcapacity” is to blame for the West’s rising trade deficits and persistent inability to reindustrialise.

China has responded firmly to these accusations. In a meeting with French President Emmanuel Macron and the European Commission’s Ursula von der Leyen in May, Chinese President Xi Jinping said that there is no such thing as “China’s overcapacity problem”, and emphasised China’s contribution to the green transition. China’s Foreign Ministry said that the “overcapacity” thesis was a “pretext” to create new restrictions on China’s energy products.

China’s “overcapacity” and the West’s industrial decline

Overcapacity can be measured in three ways. First, we can look at the “capacity utilisation rate”, or the degree to which available industrial capacity is being used. Second, we can look at........

© Pearls and Irritations