What Can Texans Learn From Their Own Left Populist Roots?
CounterPunch Exclusives
CounterPunch Exclusives
What Can Texans Learn From Their Own Left Populist Roots?
This photograph was staged by photographer Solomon D. Butcher to illustrate fence cutters and the tensions between farmers and ranchers created by the appearance of homesteads on the open range. It is unlikely, however, that these desperadoes were likely to do much damage with their wooden wire cutters, a detail lost on many historians over the years who published this photograph as a historical event. (Nebraska State Historical Society)
Long before the Lone Star State started shifting, in the 1990s, from blue to red—after a century of Democratic Party domination—some working-class Texans had a reputation for being a different kind of “red.”
They were the radical farmers and laborers who formed the backbone of the People’s Party and later the Socialist Party in the southwest. Their rise and decline as grassroots critics of both major political parties is now chronicled in a new book called The Myth of Red Texas: Cowboys, Populism, and Class War in the Radical South (Nation Books, 2026).
Red Texas is not your standard ramble through Old West lore. Instead, it focuses on popular agitation for social and economic justice in the age of the original robber barons. Its author is David Griscom, a writer and political activist based in Austin. In addition to exploring Southern labor history, he co-hosts a podcast called Left Reckoning, which regularly critiques the shortcomings of MAGA Republicans and their putative foes in the Democratic Party.
In a recent article for Jacobin, he took Texas Democrats to task for their misguided “belief that that some combination of mobilization and favorable demographic shifts will deliver victory. It’s the kind of thinking that inspires passive campaigns and disastrous election results.” The opposite of this approach, Griscom writes, is the kind of working-class politics represented by James Talarico, who won Texas’s Democratic Party Senate primary in March. Such class-centered campaigning “is about convincing voters to see politics in a new light and see themselves as members of a larger group of working people, bucking the culture war, and uniting around a simple message of economic populism.”
In this interview, we asked Griscom what lessons from the past—drawn from his state’s largely forgotten history—might be useful in present day campaigns against the big money and corporate power that’s riding high again in Texas and too many other states.
Steve Early: Many Americans live in places where the only brand of “economic populism” on offer today is the MAGA version. It’s business-friendly and anti-labor, has a lot of elite backing and is often riddled with nativism and racism. You’ve written a new book that deals with an older form of populism found in Texas and other rural states more than a century ago. What’s the difference between that populism and the Trump product on sale today?
David Griscom: I think populism probably is one of the most abused words in American politics. As the label is often applied now, you’re a populist if you use any kind of “us against them” rhetoric. In the Texas populist movement, there was certainly plenty of that. But it was coming from everyday people who were talking about themselves versus the railroad industry, the big banks and a state government beholden to these special interests. That kind of economic populism reflects real personal experience, and it has the potential to unite working people around shared economic interests.
SE: What motivated you to debunk the “myth of Red Texas”? I understand that President Lyndon Johnson’s grandfather, Samuel Johnson Sr., was once a People’s Party leader in Texas, before his grandson became a New Deal Democrat who articulated his vision of “the Great Society.” Did you have any similar family ties to populism?
DG: There are a few reasons I wanted to write the book. I’ve always found this history to be very interesting, and we find ourselves to be in a similar political moment. One of my favorite quotes from an early populist leader posed the enduring question: “Why is it that those who work most get least, and those who work least get most?” As I look around right now, I see a lot of people asking similar questions. Like small farmers in Texas during the 1870s, 1880s and the 1890s, many working people today are finding that the current system isn’t working very well for them.
They’ve been betrayed by both the political elite and the economic elite, and some are actively trying to figure out how to push back. That makes this a good moment to write about populism, in its original form, asking similar questions about how you link people across different regions and states. How do you organize industrial and agricultural workers? And unite them around common interests?
These are major political questions that progressives are still wrestling with today. As a Texan, and a very proud one, I’ve always been interested in the state’s history. But I often found that the story of everyday working people took second place to grand narratives that focused on a single individual, usually a larger-than-life Texas character.
Now, in my book, there’s plenty of fascinating folks. But one of the striking things about this era was just how expansive the populist and socialist movements were. They weren’t just about one individual doing good things in politics; they were rooted in collective action. Everyday people came together, fought for a better life, and developed the capacity to govern themselves.
SE: Can you give us any little-known highlights of your state’s agrarian radical traditions?
So much of the official history of Texas emphasizes the role of the elites—the bosses and the masters—not everyday people. In Red Texas, I tell the story of the “fence cutters.”
Texas wasn’t as devastated during the Civil War as the rest of the Confederacy. So, afterwards, there was a great deal of Northern and British investor interest in the state. These absentee owners started buying up tremendous amounts of land. And that massive bonanza coincided with the invention of barbed wire.
Previously, there had been an actual physical limit to how much land you could claim for yourself. If you have to build a fence out of rock, there’s only so many rocks that you can pull from the ground. The new capitalist........
