STEINGARD | The Chi Phi Punishments Were Not an Anomaly
In the recent Jane Doe case, a former Cornell student alleges that she was gang raped by seven members of the Chi Phi fraternity. Her complaint accuses Cornell of “failing to discipline or remove” the seven men from campus afterwards. Records obtained by The New York Times have since revealed that Cornell did punish, to varying degrees, all seven. Cornell removed four from campus, two by expulsion and two by suspension. Is that level of punishment standard for Cornell?
From 2017 to 2024, Cornell posted on its Title IX website that it found 28 students responsible for sexual misconduct. It removed 13 of them, just under half. In the Jane Doe case, removing four of the seven students it punished follows the same pattern. But does the removal rate track with other schools?
Cornell files annual reports on sexual misconduct with New York State. Those reports show that since 2018 Cornell removed 41% of students found responsible. Each of the seven other large universities in New York that found at least 15 students responsible removed at least 52%.
Source: New York State filings, 2018–2024.
Among the Ivy League schools that publish numbers for similar offenses, Cornell has the lowest rate of removal. Columbia University removed 80% of students it found responsible, Yale University 77% and Dartmouth College 60%. But Cornell has not always had such a low rate of removal.
Source: Yale, Dartmouth, Columbia, and Cornell annual sexual misconduct reports.
The New York State data only goes from 2018-2024. Cornell started publishing outcomes in 2014. From 2014-2017 it removed 17 of the 20 students it found responsible. The data, which has since been archived, shows Cornell’s removal rate........
