The Constitution’s Citizenship Conundrum
The Constitution’s Citizenship Conundrum
Inside the originalist clash between the Elections and Qualifications Clauses
Marc Garrett | November 16, 2026
The Supreme Court has offered up some real stunners, but few more egregious than Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council (2013). There, the Court ruled that states “must accept and use” the National Voter Registration Act’s (NVRA) federal registration form, which requires registrants to be citizens, but in what can only be described as theater of the absurd, it ruled that states could not require registrants to show proof of that citizenship.
The great Ronald Reagan famously said, “Trust, but verify.” But here, the not-so-great Court tells us, “Trust, no buts.”
Question: Are you carrying any explosives aboard?
Response: Wonderful, have a nice flight.
Thomas, of course, dissented, writing that the decision had “no support in the historical record.” Alito was even more colorful, writing that “the Court has it exactly backwards” and that its interpretation “produces truly strange results.”
Well, Arizona now literally has two voter-registration forms—the federal form and its own state form—and two types of ballots: one limited to federal elections and the other covering federal, state, and local elections. If you use the state form, you must present proof of citizenship. If you do, you qualify for a full ballot; if you don’t, you can’t vote at all.
But thanks to Inter Tribal, if you use the federal form, the Court forbids Arizona from requiring proof of citizenship. Instead, it will try to verify your citizenship through other means, but if it can’t, you still get to vote in federal elections on a federal-only ballot.
OK, sure, it’s absurd, but does it matter? Arizona now has 30,896 federal-only registrants, both active and inactive, without documented proof of citizenship. In the 2020 presidential election, Joe Biden carried Arizona by just 10,457 votes. You do the math.
One might think that after such a prodigious victory, Democrats would be satisfied, but no, they are now back at the Court for more. On December 8, the arguments the Court in RNC v. Mi Familia Vota will hear that are relevant to this essay reflect Democrats’ hope to further emasculate Arizona by demanding that registrants using the state........
