The Problem With The ‘Great Replacement’
The Problem With The ‘Great Replacement’
Conservatives who want to win on immigration should drop a French writer’s slogan and fix the rules that move the numbers
Jay Rogers | November 14, 2026
Pass the stuffing this Thanksgiving, and somebody at your table will remind you that Biden let in over 10 million illegals. Somebody else will call the Great Replacement a conspiracy theory and retreat to the kids’ table. Each holds half the story. After 30 years in finance and more than a decade testifying as an expert witness, I’ve watched the side with the wrong number lose arguments it should have won.
My position runs like this. The border surge under Biden was calculated and devastating, and bad policy produced it. The Great Replacement, which alleges a coordinated elite plot to swap one people for another, remains a theory. Conservatives who want to win on immigration should drop a French writer’s slogan and fix the rules that move the numbers, starting with how we count residents.
Start with the 10 million. Customs and Border Protection logged nearly 10.5 million encounters from February 2021 through September 2024, but an encounter records a stop, and one person can generate several. Someone caught three times counts three times, and more than 4.2 million of those encounters ended in deportation. Treating 10.5 million encounters as 10.5 million new residents is like counting every trip to Costco as a new membership.
The real figure needs no embellishment. Pew Research estimates the illegal alien population climbed from 10.5 million in 2021 to 14 million in 2023, its largest two-year jump in more than 30 years of estimates. Pew traces most of that growth to people who arrived with temporary protection, such as asylum applicants and parolees, and about 6 million of the 14 million held some shield from deportation. Illegal aliens made up 4.1% of the U.S. population in 2023, roughly one resident in........
