Americans Trust Canada in Trade Talks More than Their Own Government

Philippe J. Fournier

The Walrus

0
monday

Fact-based journalism that sparks the Canadian conversation

Articles Business Environment Health Politics Arts & Culture Society

Special Series Hope You’re Well For the Love of the Game Living Rooms In Other Worlds: A Space Exploration Terra Cognita More special series >

For the Love of the Game

In Other Worlds: A Space Exploration

More special series >

Events The Walrus Talks The Walrus Video Room The Walrus Leadership Roundtables The Walrus Leadership Forums Article Club

The Walrus Video Room

The Walrus Leadership Roundtables

The Walrus Leadership Forums

Subscribe Renew your subscription Change your address Magazine Issues Newsletters Podcasts

Renew your subscription

The Walrus Lab Hire The Walrus Lab Amazon First Novel Award

Amazon First Novel Award

Americans Trust Canada in Trade Talks More than Their Own Government

New poll suggests most believe Canada negotiates in good faith

F or years, Canadians have operated on two competing assumptions: that Americans like them and that Americans barely think of them at all. New polling from Leger suggests both instincts are correct, even amid continued trade tensions between Ottawa and Washington.

In a survey of 1,004 American voters conducted April 17–20, Canada remains one of the few nations Americans still view with overwhelming warmth. Asked how they would describe Canada in the context of the economic and trade relationship, a majority characterize the country in broadly positive terms.

But the data is shaded with warning. That goodwill is no longer as solid, instinctive, or politically untouchable as it once seemed. Compared with a similar Leger survey from October, the share of Americans who describe Canada as either a “close ally” or a “friendly partner” has dropped by seven points. Over the same period, the proportion who see Canada as an “unfriendly neighbour” or even an “adversary” has climbed from 13 to 18 percent.

These are not dramatic swings. They point, instead, to a shift—less a rupture than a gradual fraying that could grow more significant if negotiations over the Canada–United States–Mexico Agreement continue to stall in the months ahead.

Even as affection for Canada is showing signs of strain, one perception has remained remarkably consistent. Fully 30 percent of Americans describe Canada as a “neutral neighbour with limited impact on U.S. affairs”—a figure unchanged from last fall. In other words, Canada occupies a particular place in the American imagination: generally liked, rarely seen as hostile, peripheral to its interests.

That sense of being non-threatening appears to carry an important dividend. Americans still view Canada as an honest actor. When asked whether the country is negotiating in good faith during recent trade disputes, 57 percent of Americans say they trust Canada to seek a fair outcome. Only 22 percent say they don’t.

These numbers show only minimal erosion when compared to last fall. More strikingly, this relatively high level of trust extends across the political spectrum.

Even among Republican voters, 53 percent say they trust Canada, while 33 percent do not—a net trust score of plus twenty. Among Democratic voters, Leger measured much higher levels of confidence: 71 percent trust, 12 percent distrust. Partisan differences exist, but by the standards of contemporary American polarization, they remain surprisingly modest.

Contrast that with US attitudes toward Donald Trump’s administration. Just 42 percent of Americans say they trust their own government to negotiate in good faith, while 44 percent say they do not.

Here, the split is not just one of degree but of tribal divisions running through American politics. Republican voters overwhelmingly express trust in the administration’s intentions, while Democratic voters are just as likely to say the opposite. Independents fall somewhere in between but lean negative by a ten-point margin (47 percent distrust, 37 percent trust).

In other words, while Americans may disagree about Canada, they disagree far more—and far more sharply—about their own negotiators.

Sorry, Trump. Americans Still See Canada as a Friend

I Spent Decades Working with American Officials. The Country I Knew Is Gone

The United States Has Gone Full Villain

Economic quarrels aside, a majority of Americans continue to view the broader ties between the two countries in positive terms. More than half (54 percent) describe the US–Canada relationship as either “excellent” or “good,” compared with 29 percent who say it is “poor” or “very poor.”

Interestingly, the Canada–US relationship does not appear to trigger the same ideological fractures that shape attitudes toward the US government. If anything, Republican respondents are somewhat more likely than Democrats to view Canada positively—a reminder that perceptions of the country do not map neatly onto America’s domestic divides.

The result is a bilateral bond that, even in a period of friction, appears mostly stable in the eyes of Americans.

Still, the numbers hint at limits. With nearly one-third of Americans now viewing the relationship negatively, the margin for further deterioration is not insignificant. Small shifts—a few points away from “friendly partner,” a few points toward “unfriendly neighbour”—do not transform the relationship overnight. But they do suggest that perceptions are not immune from political and economic skirmishes.

The picture that emerges is one of profound asymmetry.

Canada remains, for most Americans, a trusted and generally friendly country. Canadian polling tells a different story. Views of the US have deteriorated sharply since Trump’s return to the White House and his administration’s increasingly confrontational posture. A recent poll from Vancouver-based Research Co. found that only 30 percent of Canadians view the US favourably, compared with 62 percent unfavourably—numbers closer to Canadian opinions of countries like Saudi Arabia or Russia.

For Canada, being seen by its volatile neighbour as a reliable and trustworthy counterpart remains a significant strategic advantage—one that, for now, endures.

Trump Is Thirsty for Canada’s Water, but Our Own Gluttony Is the Bigger Threat

April 27, 2026April 26, 2026

There’s a Way to Bring Down Food Prices. Ottawa Will Hate It

April 23, 2026April 24, 2026

Why So Many Mayors Are Quitting

April 23, 2026April 23, 2026

Support Independent Canadian Reporting and Storytelling

The Walrus is located within the bounds of Treaty 13 signed with the Mississaugas of the Credit. This land is also the traditional territory of the Anishnabeg, the Haudenosaunee, and the Wendat peoples.

The Walrus uses cookies for personalization, to customize its online advertisements, and for other purposes. Learn more or change your cookie preferences.

The Walrus is one of Canada’s last fact-checked newsrooms. Keep The Walrus free and independent.

Not ready to donate just yet? Sign up to our free newsletter so you never miss a story.

The Walrus is one of Canada’s last fact-checked newsrooms. Keep The Walrus free and independent.

Not ready to donate just yet? Sign up to our free newsletter so you never miss a story.

The Walrus is one of Canada’s last fact-checked newsrooms. Keep The Walrus free and independent.

Not ready to donate just yet? Sign up to our free newsletter so you never miss a story.

The Walrus is one of Canada’s last fact-checked newsrooms. Keep The Walrus free and independent.

Not ready to donate just yet? Sign up to our free newsletter so you never miss a story.

You see these messages all over our articles. But there’s a reason: The Walrus isn’t paywalled. We want you to choose to give (and we think you might want to).

If you donate, you become a part of The Walrus Plus: the community that’s fighting to sustain real journalism.

When you click the button below, it gets The Walrus in front of someone new because of you. You’ll bring fact-checked information to someone who wants to read it.

Will you contribute to us this month and give the gift of the news?