Take our Depression Test

Find a therapist near me

Psychiatric diagnosis relies on symptom checklists, not on identifying underlying causes of suffering.

Misdiagnosis doesn't just delay treatment—the wrong medications can actively worsen the illness.

The people closest to the patient often ask the questions the clinical system is not designed to ask.

When the map is wrong, every step taken in good faith carries the patient further from help.

Dr. H’s office sat high above Michigan Avenue in Chicago, and on clear days the view took in a long sweep of the city I loved—the lake flat and silver to the east, the grid of streets extending westward. The office itself was full of books and small sculptures, the room of a man who believed the psyche was a thing worth taking seriously. I had found this reassuring once.

By the summer of 2016, sitting in the chair across from his desk, I could no longer feel the city below as something that belonged to me.

When I asked him what he thought was wrong with me, he offered two diagnoses: major depressive disorder and generalized anxiety disorder. Both came from the DSM, psychiatry’s diagnostic manual. Both were delivered with the confidence of a man who had practiced for 40 years.

For over three decades, I had never experienced depression for any significant stretch of time. I was constitutionally, almost aggressively optimistic—the friend people called when they needed cheering up, not the one who called in distress. Anxiety before a lecture or a deadline, yes, but a clinical disorder? The labels felt like a coat cut for someone else’s body: technically mine, functionally wrong, a daily reminder that the person being treated was not quite the person who had arrived.

What I could not yet see—what no one in that room could see—was that my suffering was real but had been misidentified at its root. I was experiencing the crash side of a bipolar illness that would not be correctly named for another four years. And something else was happening that neither checklist nor clinical interview could reach: a syphilis infection, progressing quietly through my nervous system, mimicking psychiatric illness with eerie........

© Psychology Today