Truth, evidence and controversy: Richard Dawkins’ The God Delusion at 20
In my youth, somewhere in the late 1990s, when I was a goth or a punk or something, I had a t-shirt proclaiming, “Ignorance should not reproduce”. Along with the text there was a provocative image, which included the Christian cross.
Back then, if you were an educated liberal type, who valued reasoning and evidence, the scientific method, free expression and broadly progressive social values – the kinds of values championed by civil rights movements – there was a decent chance that you felt yourself to be battling against a stuffy, illiberal Christian orthodoxy that, to a considerable extent, held the reins of power, especially in the United States.
In 1999, at a Republican primary debate, the presidential candidates were asked “what political philosopher or thinker do you most identify with?” Without missing a beat, George W. Bush said “Christ”. This was arguably the moment he became the frontrunner to become president.
Religion and power commingled. This was not only a concern in politics, but in education, where we often heard about intelligent design being taught alongside natural selection.
Rereading Richard Dawkin’s The God Delusion, which turned 20 this year, I’m reminded of this time. The God Delusion offers a sustained critique of religion, and Christianity, in particular. Its arguments are presented across ten chapters, the most significant being the fourth, titled “Why There Almost Certainly is No God”.
The book was a huge bestseller – it sold more than three million copies and was translated into more than 30 languages. It struck at the heart of the religious leviathan, at least for its educated, secular readership.
It was also immensely controversial, with many significant rebuttals being published. There were three main objections.
First, Dawkins was accused of engaging with a caricature of religious faith. Literary scholar Terry Eagleton famously accused Dawkins and others of producing “vulgar caricatures of religious faith that would make a first-year theology student wince.”
Second, he was criticised for his tone. Theologian Alister McGrath spoke of Dawkins’ “shrill, aggressive rhetoric”.
Third, Dawkins was accused of replacing one religion with another – science. The title of novelist Marilynne Robinson’s 2006 article about Dawkins’ book, Hysterical Scientism, very much conveys this. (I’ll return to this last objection at the end.)
Notably, opposition to The God Delusion took the form of intellectual debate. He wasn’t “de-platformed” – cancelled – in any significant way.
Still, Dawkins, the evolutionary biologist, who made his name with The Selfish Gene (1976), became one of the “Four Horsemen of New Atheism”, along with the brilliant and polemical journalist Christopher Hitchens (God Is Not Great, 2007), cognitive scientist Daniel Dennett (Breaking the Spell, 2006), and philosopher Sam Harris (The End of Faith, 2004, and Letter to a Christian Nation, 2006).
Today,........
