Behind a bad call: How Michelle Guthrie became managing director of the ABC
In November 2015, the ABC board was approaching its most important task – the selection of a new managing director, ahead of Mark Scott’s departure after a decade in the role.
The process which resulted in the appointment of Michelle Guthrie was dominated by board chairman Jim Spigelman. It was also notable for the number and quality of candidates who applied and who were apparently lightly passed over.
The criteria for the job included leadership qualities, broadcast experience and a strong understanding of digital media and its implications, but there was another, less explicit criterion. It was widely known that Spigelman had a strong preference for the next managing director to be a woman – the first to hold the post.
In fact, Spigelman had had a different woman in mind. He wanted Kate Torney, the director of news, to apply. Torney had been spotted early as management talent, first by Russell Balding and then by Scott. In researching this book, I heard catty remarks and criticisms of every member of the ABC executive from within the ABC – except for Torney. After seven years as director of news, she was well respected. Many saw her as the natural successor to Scott and hoped that it would be so.
Going Digital: The Transformation of the ABC, by Margaret Simons, will be released 3 November 2026, published by Black Inc
But in July 2015, Torney announced that she would be leaving the ABC. In theory, this would not have stopped her from applying for the managing director’s role, and both Spigelman and Scott tried to convince her to do so, but Torney ruled herself out of contention. There were multiple reasons. She had never hungered for the top job. Being director of news had been all-consuming, and she was very tired. Moreover, she had concluded that the ABC needed “a lot of clearing up”. Part of this was a legacy of Scott’s decision not to fundamentally restructure the organisation in the wake of the brutal 2014 funding cuts, but in her view it was now overdue.
Spigelman told me that losing Torney as a contender for the managing director’s job was his biggest regret. In his view, it robbed the recruitment process of one of the strongest contenders.
Recruitment consultants Egon Zehnder came up with a list of 150 names as a result of a worldwide search. Michelle Guthrie’s name was on that list. So was that of a former holder of senior ABC jobs and a dedicated ABC watcher: Kim Williams. Williams had been circling the ABC his entire life, even though the most recent chapter of his career had been at News Corporation. He and Spigelman were close friends of long standing.
As a journalist reporting on the ABC during Scott’s tenure, it was sometimes difficult for me to find cogent........
