Don Rittner’s column: The Real Gilded Age – Part One
I spent a couple of seasons working on HBO’s The Gilded Age. Honestly, the show looks spectacular with those fancy ballrooms, the clothes, the rivalry between old and new money; it’s all a real treat for the eyes. Julian Fellowes is clearly in his element, and the series has swept up fans around the world. Still, I have to be blunt: as history, The Gilded Age drops the (gilded) ball. By a lot.
Let’s start with the way New York society gets painted. The series loves that old money vs. new money showdown, but the real Gilded Age was way messier. Certainly you had millionaires throwing fancy parties, but just a few streets over, people lived in crowded, filthy tenements. Immigrants crammed into ratty apartments, child labor was everywhere, strikes rattled the city, and political corruption ran wild. Crime, disease, and ethnic conflict were part of daily life. The show, though, mostly sticks with the silk-and-diamonds crowd and only tosses the rest a passing nod.
The dialogue? Often it feels like they’ve time-traveled from 2026. They spout off about race, gender, and class in ways that most people, especially the rich and powerful, never would have back then. Progressive attitudes weren’t just uncommon among elites; they were shocking, sometimes even dangerous.........
