14 key facts about the DEFIANCE Act and Paris Hilton's push for it
Get Quartz in your inbox
Free daily briefing on global business news.
Privacy and Cookie Settings
14 key facts about the DEFIANCE Act and Paris Hilton's push for it
14 facts on the DEFIANCE Act, from the right to sue and damages to Paris Hilton's push and the House vote that has not happened.
Sexual deepfakes have stopped being an occasional celebrity scandal and become something people produce in bulk. The number of nonconsensual deepfake porn videos online has grown ninefold since 2019, according to one researcher's count reported by the Senate Judiciary Committee. The volume has since moved well past the figures in the policy debate. At least 1.8 million explicit images were shared through the Grok chatbot in just nine days, according to a New York Times analysis reported by ABC News. For a victim, the problem is no longer a single image to report and remove but an unknown number of copies spread across the internet. Few people defend the practice. In a poll published in 2024, 84% of respondents told the Artificial Intelligence Policy Institute that deepfake porn should be illegal, according to TIME. The harm itself is not in dispute.
That broad agreement has not given victims a federal way to go after the person behind an image themselves. The argument in Washington is over which tool fits the harm. Prosecutors could bring criminal charges, platforms could be forced to take images down, or victims could file lawsuits that they control. The DEFIANCE Act would supply the third option, and even it would have a hard edge. The bill would apply in the United States only, according to ABC News. A creator working from another country would fall outside its remedy. Because of that limit, the real test of each provision is what it can do for a victim and what it cannot.
Congress.gov set out to outline what the DEFIANCE Act does and why Paris Hilton backs it, weighing the bill's mechanics alongside its most visible champion, from suing under a pseudonym to the time victims would have to bring a case and the end of the "it's only a fake" defense. Every one of those protections is conditional. The bill has passed the Senate, but the House has not voted, so none of these rights exists yet for anyone harmed by a sexual deepfake. Two questions remain for each provision: whether it fills a gap that existing law leaves open, and whether a lawsuit would work against creators who are anonymous or hard to find.
The DEFIANCE Act would let the person shown in a sexual deepfake decide whether a case goes forward. Under the bill, someone depicted in such an image could file a civil suit in federal court against whoever made or spread it, according to Congress.gov. Rep. Joe Morelle's separate federal proposal, the Preventing Deepfakes of Intimate Images Act, was a criminal bill, according to TIME. Under a criminal law, prosecutors decide which cases to bring. Under DEFIANCE, a victim would not have to wait for her case to become a prosecutor's priority before someone answers for the harm. The bill would also cover more people than the one who made the image. A person who shares or publishes a deepfake made by someone else could be sued, and passing an image along would carry its own legal risk. Anyone who solicits a deepfake could be sued as well, which reaches the person who commissions an image before it exists. A threat to distribute one would be grounds for a suit on its own. A victim facing blackmail could go to court before the image ever spreads.
A federal claim would give victims the same standing in every state. In January 2024, only ten states had criminal laws against nonconsensual deepfakes, and Morelle's criminal bill had seen no action since its introduction, according to TIME. A civil suit in federal court would not depend on where a victim lives or on what her state legislature has passed. The bill's backers present it as a right that belongs to the victim, not as a crackdown run by the government. "Innocent people have a right to defend their reputations and hold perpetrators accountable in court," Sen. Josh Hawley, one of four lawmakers who introduced the bill, said.
A lawsuit can make a person pay, but it cannot by itself remove an image from the internet. A victim could win her case and still find the picture online. Keeping deepfakes off social media will take a commitment of resources from the companies that run those sites, and legislation alone will not do it, according to comments by Nina Brown, a Syracuse University professor of media law and technology, reported by TIME. The bill would give a victim leverage over the person behind an image, but not over the sites that host it.
That leaves an open question: whether a victim can identify and reach the person she needs to sue.
A victim who wins a DEFIANCE Act case could leave court with more than a check, because a judge could also order the images taken offline and make the defendant cover her legal costs, according to CNBC. Those two remedies address a victim's most practical needs: getting the image down and not paying for the fight herself. The bill would also let a victim seek punitive damages, an award that goes beyond repaying what she lost. Those damages penalize the person who made or spread the image. For the bill's best-known advocate, that penalty is the point. "People need to know that there's going to be consequences for their actions," said Paris Hilton, chief advocacy officer at Loti AI. Backers want the money to deter the next creator as well as to compensate the person depicted.
The bill also puts a dollar figure on a win. Damages under the DEFIANCE Act would start at $150,000, according to Bloomberg Law figures reported by Congress.gov. A victim and her lawyer would have that figure in hand when deciding whether a case is worth the time and the exposure of going to court. Taken together, the remedies would make a deepfake expensive for whoever made or spread it, from the removal order through the punitive award.
The bill pairs a way to get the image offline with a real cost for the person behind it.
Statute........
