menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

10 things to know before buying an IPO, from lockups to limit orders

5 0
yesterday

Get Quartz in your inbox

Free daily briefing on global business news.

Privacy and Cookie Settings

10 things to know before buying an IPO, from lockups to limit orders

Individual investors reach an IPO after banks, brokers and insiders. These 10 checks cover access, lockups, valuation and alternatives.

Initial public offerings used to be events that most people only read about, but brokerages now pitch them to ordinary accounts. Schwab, Fidelity, Robinhood Financial, SoFi and E-Trade are among the brokerages set to sell Anthropic shares to their customers, according to CNBC. Not every brokerage takes part in every IPO, so a customer of a different firm may have no way to request shares at all. Whether an investor can buy, and how many shares, depends on decisions that banks and brokers make well before the stock opens. The invitation to buy is real, but other people set its terms.

The price in the headlines is the offer price, and it is the price an individual investor is least likely to pay. Individuals often get their shares only once trading is under way, after the stock has moved away from the offer price and any early gain has gone to the people who bought at it. The individual's real choice is whether to buy a stock that has already traded, and at what price. Nobody can tell at the start whether a newly listed company will reward the people who hold it for years. For the buyer, the work moves from getting shares to deciding whether they are worth owning. That decision rests on checks the buyer can actually make: what the company discloses, whether its price holds up, who is cashing out and how much of a portfolio to put at risk.

J.P. Morgan Wealth Management set out to show ordinary investors how to get into IPOs, which risks come with buying them, how to study an offering before ordering and which other options they have. The questions include how long insiders must wait before they can sell, who is selling the shares and whether to buy an IPO at all. Many of the answers depend on someone other than the buyer, whether underwriters, brokers or the company's own insiders. The buyer acts last, after all of them, and what matters is what that position means for the buyer's money. Some of these checks end with a purchase. Others lead to a different question: whether the same exposure is available more cheaply and more steadily elsewhere.

IPO price versus open-market price

An individual's price for a new stock depends on the moment the order fills, and that moment arrives in a window the buyer doesn't control. The offer price is set in advance, but buyers and sellers can move the price sharply once trading begins, according to J.P. Morgan Wealth Management. SpaceX set its offer at $135 a share, and the stock opened at $150, according to CNBC. Trading in a new listing is also often delayed past the opening bell, so an order placed at the start of the day simply waits while other traders settle on a price. By the time it can fill, the only question left is which moment of the session the buyer gets.

Two people can buy the same stock on the same day and finish the session on opposite sides. Buyers pushed SpaceX as high as $176.52 during its first day, CNBC reports, and it closed at $160.95. A buyer who paid the day's high ended the session with a loss, while a buyer who paid the opening price ended it with a gain. Even veterans of the business can't forecast that path. "You never know what retail buyers are going to do with stock after it opens," Dan Alpert, founder of Westwood Capital, told CNBC. An order to buy at whatever price sellers ask on day one is a bet on the moment, not on the company.

A strong debut looks certain in hindsight, but investors could have sent the same stock lower. CNBC reports that Paul Meeks, head of technology research at Freedom Capital Markets, believes SpaceX shares might have fallen on their first day instead of rising. Investors can sell a new listing below its offer price when underwriters price it aggressively, when the broader market is weak, or when enthusiasm is low. When a stock does jump, the cause stays unclear. Buyers may bid it up out of real excitement, or because underwriters set a conservative offer price, and the first-day move alone doesn't show which.

The first day's trading shows how eager buyers were for a single session, and whether the price is worth paying depends on the company itself.

Institutional buyers get most shares

The first shares of a new stock are spoken for before the public can trade it, and individual investors are served last. J.P. Morgan Wealth Management says that the banks running a new issue, known as underwriters, hand the bulk of the opening allocation to large institutions, so most individuals have to buy after trading starts. Those institutions are pension, mutual and hedge funds, and any one of them can place an order far larger than an individual's. Even the shares that do reach individuals come with no guarantee, so a request for stock at the offer price can go unfilled. For an individual, buying at the offer price is the exception and not something to count on.

The tilt toward big funds looks like banks favoring their best clients, but bargaining power alone can produce it. In one example worked through in a theoretical model, an underwriter gives every share of a new issue to the single investor holding over 50% of the market's capacity to bear the stock's risk, according to a 2006 discussion paper from the Federal Reserve Board. An investor that large could sell into the new stock and push its price down once trading opens, which gives the underwriter every reason to keep it satisfied. That logic fits the real pattern of big funds receiving most shares. In that example, the large investor wins the shares........

© Quartz