menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

Metascores explained: weights, color bands and the games that came close to 99

3 0
yesterday

Get Quartz in your inbox

Free daily briefing on global business news.

Privacy and Cookie Settings

Metascores explained: weights, color bands and the games that came close to 99

How Metacritic scores work, from weighted critic averages and color-coded score bands to why a 99 Metascore requires near-unanimous top marks from critics

A Metascore of 99 does not just show that critics liked something. It shows that almost none of them held back. Metacritic turns a set of published reviews into a single number. That compression changes what the top of the scale means. A high score reflects praise. A near-perfect score reflects agreement.

Metacritic covers video games, films, TV shows and music albums. For each title, it gathers reviews from professional critics and publications. It then reports one figure on a scale of 0 to 100. That figure is the Metascore. It condenses many separate verdicts into one number a reader can take in at a glance.

The number looks simple, but several decisions sit behind it. Not every critic counts equally. Metacritic gives more weight to some publications than to others. It does not publish those weights. Many reviews arrive without a 100-point score at all. A star rating, a letter grade or a score out of 10 has to be translated before it can join the average. The finished number is then placed in a green, yellow or red band. Those bands are not the same for every medium.

Understanding how Metacritic scores work also explains why the very top of the scale stays so empty. The Metascore is an average. One lukewarm review can pull a title below a perfect mark. Reaching 99 requires nearly every counted critic to give a top or near-top score. The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time holds the highest score of any game on the site. It earned a 99 for its 1998 release on the Nintendo 64.

The slides that follow cover each part of the system. They explain what a Metascore measures and how weighting and score conversion work. They also lay out what the color codes mean. They look at Ocarina of Time and a selection of games just below it. They show how films and TV use the same scale, including Boyhood's 100. Later slides separate the critic score from the user score. The user score runs from 0 to 10 and has been targeted by organized review bombing. The final slide compares Metacritic with Rotten Tomatoes. Its Tomatometer measures something different: the share of reviews judged positive, not the strength of the praise.

What a Metascore is and what Metacritic measures

A Metascore is a single number from 0 to 100 that summarizes what published critics thought of a game, film, TV show or album. Metacritic gathers those professional reviews and condenses them into that one figure.

The site itself does not issue the verdict. Its number is built from reviews that other outlets have already published. A Metascore is therefore a reading of critical consensus rather than a review in its own right.

The distinction matters for how the number should be read. A review from one magazine or website reflects one critic's judgment. A Metascore pools many of those judgments. One critic's enthusiasm or dislike carries less force inside that pool than it does on its own.

Each title's page shows the Metascore next to the number of critic reviews behind it. The same page lists the individual reviews. Each entry names the publication, shows the score assigned to that review and quotes a short excerpt, usually with a link to the full piece.

The scale is shared across media, but the media are not interchangeable. Reviews of a film and reviews of a game come largely from different critics and different publications. Comparing a game's Metascore with a film's Metascore compares two separate pools of reviewers, not two works judged by the same panel.

What the Metascore measures is professional criticism. Audience ratings sit in a separate user score. The Metascore is meant to answer one narrow question: across the published reviews Metacritic counts, how favorably did critics rate this work?

A Metascore also moves. Scores can change as additional reviews are added after release. A number checked on launch day may not match the number shown months later.

Each Metascore is a snapshot of critical opinion at a given moment. It is shorthand for many reviews, and the reviews themselves still hold the detail behind the number.

How Metacritic's weighted average works

A Metascore is a weighted average, not a simple one. Metacritic says it gives some critics and publications more influence than others, based on their quality and stature. It does not publish how much any outlet counts.

That design choice separates Metacritic from a plain calculator. In a simple average, every review pulls on the final number with equal force. A small blog and a major national outlet would each move the result by the same amount.

A weighted average changes that balance. In this kind of calculation, each score is multiplied by a factor that reflects how much the aggregator trusts its source. The weighted scores are then added together. That total is divided by the sum of the weights, not by the number of reviews.

The practical effect is that a heavily weighted review shifts a Metascore more than a lightly weighted one. A harsh verdict from a publication Metacritic rates highly can drag a score down further than a harsh review from an outlet it rates lower. Strong praise works the same way, lifting the number more when it comes from a higher-weighted critic.

Metacritic has not released a list........

© Quartz