Ever since I sold my plasma to buy a copy of Bloodborne back in 2015 (college — wild times!), I’ve been a big Soulslike guy. The challenge, the triumph, the opacity, the bounty of “OH SHIT” moments — I can’t get enough of them. Yet, until the recently released Valor Mortis, I’ve never played a Soulslike in first-person point of view, which is usually associated with a subsection of shooters.

Now that I’ve spent some time fighting the plagued soldiers of Napoleon’s army in Valor Mortis, I’m not sold on its first-person Soulslike bona fides. The difficulty is there, as is the annoying “lose your XP on death” mechanic. But it doesn’t quite translate that distinct combat experience to first-person, and instead shows the limitations of such an endeavor.

Most Soulslikes are played in third-person, a janky camera positioned behind your character. Combat typically involves hacking at opponents with a melee weapon while dodge-rolling to avoid their blows. Sometimes magic or a robot arm, like in Lies of P, offers variety and new ways of tackling opponents.

There’s also a spatial awareness necessary to Soulslike combat that Valor Mortis just can’t capture in first-person. Picture it: You’re wandering through the........

© Polygon