menu_open Columnists
We use cookies to provide some features and experiences in QOSHE

More information  .  Close

US failed narrative of deterrence toward Iran

56 0
previous day

THOUGH President Trump has ruled out to use the nuclear option against Iran, strategists argue that President Trump’s intermittent threat to use the option of an ultimate weapon against Iran was and is by no means calibrated deterrence—rather, it sets a dangerous precedent that breaks down strategic maturity. This observation/argument is further supported by Richard Haass insightful article in the Project Syndicate, ‘’Trump’s Risky War of Choice in Iran (1 March 2026). Haass argues, this was not a war of necessity but ‘’a war of choice’’—a preventive war where ‘’ Iran posed no imminent threat to vital US interests’’. Needless to say, if deterrence fails, executing or invoking a threat doesn’t simply achieve a political goal, rather, it ensues total ruin for both sides. Thus, relying on inherently irrational act is not a stable strategy, but a systemic failure of rational statecraft.

Analytically examining, Trump’s two-pronged approach toward Iran combined diplomatic engagement with aggressive rhetoric and policy shifts, exemplified by withdrawing from the JCPOA and adopting a ‘maximum pressure’ campaign. Further, owing to its escalatory risks and disregard for multilateral agreements, the Trump’s strategy underwent severe foreign policy miscarriages. Unlike traditional diplomacy emphasizing dialogue and verification, Trump prioritized unilateral pressure, increasing regional tensions. Thus, this strategy undermined trust, limited negotiation avenues, and heightened fears of nuclear proliferation. Arguably, the contrast lies not in diplomacy vs. aggression per se, but in methods: one reliant on international cooperation, the other on coercion and brinkmanship.

And yet, there........

© Pakistan Observer